One of my all-time favorite pizza places in the world is back in business. The Flamingo in Cedar Rapids (see map) reopened a year and a half ago. Cindy and I were in Cedar Rapids recently for a benefit that she wanted to go to and I said I'd go with her if we could eat at the new Flamingo. She readily agreed.
I lamented the 2004 demise of the Flamingo in a post here. I was seriously bummed because they had one of the best brick-oven pizzas this side of New York City. We had noticed, however, the quality of the food sort of going down hill before they closed the doors and we weren't all that surprised when Cindy's sister, Anita, told us it had closed.
The history behind the Flamingo is long and pretty interesting. After World War II, lots were made available along Ellis Blvd. in Cedar Rapids on land that was once a grade school in the neighborhood. The American Legion post bought the land in the area and began to parcel it out for homes. The three lots the Flamingo now stands on were perfect for commercial property - primarily a hot dog/root beer stand for people going to nearby parks.
Two gentleman kept bidding higher and higher for the property until neither could go any longer. The American Legion decided that a coin flip would determine the winner of the bid on the property. The winner, Dick Berzinski, opened the Park Lane Drive-Inn in May of 1947. A dining room was added in 1948 and the original building became the kitchen area.
In 1951, a second room was added to the building (the room is now the Flamingo's bar area) and Berzinski added space to the kitchen and increased the storage area. He also changed the theme from a drive-in to a full service restaurant selling fish and other seafood. The Hot Fish Shoppe was the first of it's kind in Eastern Iowa.
In 1955, Berzinski moved the Hot Fish Shoppe to a new location in NW Cedar Rapids and renamed the original place the Shorewood. The Shorewood would be in business for the next seven years at this location before moving in 1962 to the northern part of Cedar Rapids. It was eventually bought by the Pillsbury Corporation for their chain of growing restaurants and became the Boar's Head - a popular chain of upscale restaurants in the Midwest in the 60's and 70's.
A gentleman by the name of George Davis bought the Shorewood building in 1962 and renamed it the Flamingo. Davis owned the Flamingo until the mid-70's. It was during this time that Davis put in the famous brick oven for pizza making - the original one that is still there today, even after surviving a devastating kitchen fire in 1987.
In 1976, Ron Godwin purchased the Flamingo and carried on the tradition of great pizzas, lunch and dinner entrees, salads and sandwiches. Godwin also remodeled the restaurant in 1980 and again in 1987 after the kitchen fire. Some of the locals gave it the nickname, "The Flaming-O" after the fire.
Now, this is where history gets a little fuzzy. I believe that Godwin sold the restaurant to some people in the late 90's and they ran it, well, they basically ran it into the ground. The restaurant closed in 2004 with a whimper. As I said before, it was not all that surprising as we had inconsistent food when we'd gone there in the couple of years coming up to the closing. One time, the pizza would be outstanding. The next, it would be lifeless and over-cooked.
In 2006, Kacy and Beth Smith bought the Flamingo building and reopened the restaurant hoping to recapture some of the magic the place had when Dick Godwin owned the place years before. They kept a lot of the favorites, changed the menu a bit, and the place seems to be going strong today.
After the benefit that Cindy wanted to go to, we drove to the Flamingo along with her sister, Anita. It was a very windy and frigid Saturday night when we got there. There was one car in the parking lot (it was 9:30 at night) and we wondered if they were open or not. We walked in and the bartender greeted us. I asked, "Are you still open?"
She said, "Oh, yes. We're open to 11, but the kitchen closes at 10."
I said, "So, we can get a pizza then, right?"
She said, "Absolutely!"
There was just one other person in the bar, sitting playing a video game. That was it. Anita said, "I don't know if this is a good sign or not. There's no one in here."
Cindy said, "Well, it is colder than hell outside. Probably not a lot of people were out."
And I said, "And if they were out, they were out earlier."
We sat in a booth in the bar area and ordered up a large pizza - sausage, pepperoni and mushroom on one half, and just sausage and pepperoni on the other (Cindy doesn't care for mushrooms). We also ordered a basket of the Flamingo's beer-battered onion rings. Anita had not been to the place since it had opened, either, so she was hoping that it would be as good as it was.
The bartender, who was also our waitress, brought us out the onion rings. They were exactly the same as before. Wonderful, flaky, tasty, greasy onion rings. Oh, they were just outstanding.
About 10 minutes later, the bartender brought out the pizza. At first glance, I was disappointed. The toppings were sparse. I mean, there was - maybe - 12 chunks of sausage on the pizza, and there wasn't a lot of pepperoni either. But the first bite into the pizza made me momentarily forget about that. The sauce was still the delicious pizza sauce they had from before. The cheese was the same wonderful taste as before. And the crust was the same thin-crust New York style where you could fold up a piece and eat it that way. I was just disappointed in the lack of toppings.
The bartender came over to check on us and she asked how everything was. I said, "Well, the taste of the pizza is excellent, just like it used to be. But I'm a little disappointed in the lack of toppings. I mean look at this."
I pointed out a piece of pizza that had NO sausage chunks on it and only two slices of pepperoni. I said, "I don't remember ever getting pizzas here that were this sparse on toppings."
She said, "Oh, well, the guy we have in the kitchen, the owners were on him because they felt he was putting too much of the toppings on the pizza. So they had him cut back. It looks like he cut back too much."
We asked her if business had been slow, given that we were the only people in the place eating. She said, "It was fairly busy earlier. But it really started to die out around 8:30. I'm sure the weather has something to do with it. Even a lot of our regulars who come to the bar didn't come in tonight."
She ended up giving us a reduced price on our pizza for the lack of toppings. Cindy said, "Now, you be sure to give her a good tip!"
So, a large pizza, onion rings, three beers and a couple of drinks came to a little over $38 bucks with tip. Basically, what she took off the price of the pizza I gave it back to her in the tip.
Other than the scarcity of toppings, the pizza was outstanding. I'm guessing we got an anomaly and not the usual thing at the Flamingo. I really want to go back sometime and give another one a try. When it's done right, it is truly one of the best pizzas I've ever had.