I put on a new dealer out in Fishers, IN last year and I've been spending a lot of time there helping them get up to speed with our products and to help with some of their planning on their new retail space in downtown Fishers. I spent the night before a meeting with them in Fishers and decided to try out a brew pub that I had seen on a previous visit to the area, a place called Four Day Ray Brewing.
Brian Graham was a longtime beer enthusiast who started to brew beer in his garage over 20 years ago. He started out with a five gallon system to brew his beers, but as he became more proficient at brewing beers his vessels grew larger and he was brewing up to what amounted to a half-barrel of beer (15.5 gallons) with each batch. In 2000, just a few short years after he started to brew his own beer, Graham won the Homebrewer Best of Show at the Indiana State Fair for his Belgian Wit.
Mitch Ackerman was also a craft brewery aficionado who ended up working as a brewers assistant at the Thirsty Dog Brewing Company in his hometown of Akron, OH. After working there for awhile, Ackerman ended up moving out to Lake Havasu City, AZ to be the head brewer at the Mudshark brewery there. As much as he liked being the head brewer Mudshark, he longed to get back to the Midwest.
In 2007, Graham opened a gastropub along 96th St. in north Indianapolis called Hot Shotz, a place he sold relatively quickly after opening the place. What Graham wanted to do was to have a combination restaurant/brewery - and not have it called a brewpub as he wanted to be able to distribute his beers to other places around the area. He eventually met Ackerman who told Graham of his strong desire to move back to the Midwest. The two teamed up on the concept of the restaurant/brewery and started to look for investors.
The Indianapolis suburb of Fishers was going through a metamorphosis in their downtown area with the new Nickel Plate District coming to fruition in 2014. Not only was the area - named after the historic Nickel Plate railroad line - going to have new local government buildings, but it would also be the site for new office buildings, residential lofts and condos, as well as retail and restaurants spaces. Graham and Ackerman got together with two of Nickel Plate's developers - Chris Welsh and Matt Troyer - to discuss their vision of a restaurant/brewery. Welsh and Troyer were so intrigued with the concept that they partnered with Graham and Welsh to get their restaurant/brewery off the ground.
The foundation for the new place was poured in February of 2016 and construction continued throughout the summer and into the early fall. The group came up with a name for the restaurant and brewery - Four Day Ray - which was a nod to a nickname Nickel Plate railroad workers would give colleagues who habitually called in sick one day a week. They also hired a seasoned chef - Andrew Miller - to run the kitchen. Miller had stints at restaurants around the Indianapolis area as well as at the Maker's Mark Center Cut Steakhouse at the Indiana Grand Casino near Shelbyville, IN.
By the fall of 2016, everything was in place for the opening. Ackerman had already been brewing beers and distributing them to a small network of bars and restaurants around Indianapolis during the summer months, so there was already a buzz about the Four Day Ray beers around the city. On October 20 of that year, Four Day Ray opened their doors and crowds were large right off the bat.
Four Day Ray is located at the southwest corner of Lantern Rd. and North St. in downtown Fishers. (see map) It's housed in a two-story building with large windows showing the brewing facility and is very prominent among the other buildings (and construction sites) in the area. Parking was a bit difficult, but I was lucky to find a spot that was literally in front of the large tanks of the brewery.
The dining area was an expansive space with a high ceiling with dozens of Edison light fixtures hanging from varying heights from the ceiling. Overhead doors along the walls could be opened during the warmer months. There was a bar area with a short wall separating the bar and the dining area. The short wall also functioned as banquette seating for a handful of tables.
The brewery, itself, is to the left as you walk in the front door of Four Day Ray. The large stainless steel tanks were gleaming in the light behind large glass partitions.
The taproom is right next to the brewing facility. The current beers on tap are shown on a flat screen television behind the bar. This is a food-free area and one that is designed for people to sit and enjoy the beer in a quiet setting. The taproom closes at 8 p.m. through the week and closes at 9:30 on Friday and Saturday.
On the mezzanine above the main bar/dining area, there is a small bar area that can be used for overflow from downstairs. There was also a private dining area up on the mezzanine that was in use the night I was there for a business function.
I ended up sitting at the bar downstairs. It was a three-sided bar with the beer taps and liquor bottles along a lighted back wall. The place was packed and the bartenders were doing their best to keep up. I sat at a seat where someone had just gotten up and the drink glass hadn't been picked up. I sat there for a few moments when one of the bartenders came by and asked if I wanted another drink. I told him that this wasn't my drink, I just sat down. He apologized, cleaned up the bar area in front of me and gave me a beer menu to check out.
And, man, did they have a lot of beers to choose from. I think they had about two dozen beers on tap that they brew at Four Day Ray. I had a lot of choices and I ended up getting the Hobo #3 India Pale Ale. It was a hoppy and forward tasting beer, but it had a nice smooth finish. I liked it immensely.
The bartender had given me a food menu after he dropped off my beer. I was in sort of a food funk from being on the road so much lately. I really didn't know what I wanted to eat that evening. I was hungry, but not that hungry. They had a lot of interesting appetizers and I considered getting the seared ahi tuna appetizer for my dinner, but I wasn't certain I really wanted that.
They had burgers, sandwiches, street tacos, and a number of salads on the menu. Main entrees included a hickory-smoked chicken breast, fish and chips, grilled salmon, and center cut beef filet medallions. I thought briefly about getting the pork tenderloin sandwich, but my stomach just wasn't up for that.
I ended up getting some of the street tacos they had on the menu. Actually, they were all very interesting and I got the tuna poke taco, a blackened fish taco, and the smoked pulled pork taco. I almost got a carne asada taco, but I decided that if I were still hungry, I could order that later. Turns out that I didn't need to.
The tuna poke taco was served on a crispy corn taco and it featured tuna sashimi topped with a ponzu sauce, Kohlrabi slaw, and a ginger aioli. It was a very delicious taco. Had I gotten all three like that, I would have been very happy.
But I like variety in my street tacos and the blackened fish taco also turned out to be very good. It was a blackened white fish topped with shaved red cabbage, pico de gallo, and a sriracha/avocado aioli. This taco was also very flavorful and if you asked me which one I liked more between the tuna poke and the blackened white fish taco, it would have been a toss-up.
Unfortunately, the pulled pork taco came in a distant third in the taco poll that evening. The pulled pork was topped with a salsa verde, a pickled red onion, and finished with cotija cheese. This one looked great on paper, but it turned out that pulled pork had a distinct petroleum aftertaste - a telltale sign that they used too much smoke in the process of cooking the meat. And that was completely disappointing as I thought the combination of the pork, the green salsa, and the pickled onions would be a winning combination.
I'll have to say that Four Day Ray is a neat place for beer and food. While I wasn't too enamored with the pulled pork taco I had, both the tuna poke taco and the blackened white fish taco were delicious. I was impressed with the large selection of beers they brew and offer at Four Day Ray, and I was more than happy with my choice of the Hobo #3 IPA that I had that evening. The three tacos were just enough food for me that evening, a night in which I wasn't really certain what I really wanted to eat that evening. I'm going to be back in Fishers a handful of times in the near future and I'm sure that I'll be parking myself at Four Day Ray again.