During the annual AXPONA show in the northwest Chicago suburb of Schaumburg this past spring, I was tasked with finding places to eat for our ever growing team that worked the show. We had gone out for Indian food the night before - something that my boss doesn't care for, but tolerates. For the next night, I asked him what he would like to have for dinner that evening. "Italian doesn't sound bad," he said with a slight smile. OK, now I had to find an Italian restaurant in Schaumburg, an area that I wasn't overly familiar with. I went on line and looked on a couple of sites - Yelp and TripAdvisor - to see what was in the area. I found a place in nearby Arlington Heights that seemed to have a consensus of good reviews - and not the kind that seemed to be canned or contrived. I made reservations through Open Table for a party of 12 at Via Arenella.
Mario and Rosa (Rose) Longobardi were longtime restaurateurs in the northwest suburbs of Chicago. They opened Ristorante Arenella in Arlington Heights in 1989 and it quickly became a favorite among the locals for a number of years. In 2009, the Longobardi's were forced to close their restaurant because the landlord wanted the space for another business. Not long after that, the Longobardi's reopened at a new location with a new name - Mario Trattoria. But by 2016, Mario and Rosa wanted to slow down a bit and they closed Mario Trattoria in the summer of that year.
The Longobardi's three sons - Alfonso (a.k.a. "Fonzo"), Franco, and Mario, Jr. - all grew up in Ristorante Arenella working after school and on the weekends in the kitchen or in the dining room. After their parents closed their restaurant, the three brothers got together and decided to open their own restaurant using many of the recipes their parents made at Ristorante Arenella.
Pictured at right - the Longobardi family. From left - Mario, Jr., Rose, Alfonso, Mario, Sr. and Franco. Photo courtesy The Daily Herald.
The brothers found a spot in a strip mall at the corner of S. Wilkie Road and W. Campbell Street for their new restaurant. (see map) With the blessing of their parents, the Longobardi brothers opened Via Arenella in early 2017. From years of learning from his father, Fonzo Longobardi took over in the kitchen as the head chef, Mario, Jr. took over the pizza oven duties serving the family's famous thin-crust pizza, and Franco - who studied hospitality management at DePaul University - oversaw the front of the house. Of course, Mario, Sr. and Rose couldn't stay away, so they help out on the weekends and some nights when the place got busy.
And the night we were there was one of those busy nights. But I had made the reservation on Open Table for 7:30 and we showed up promptly at that time. We had a couple minute wait while they put two tables together for our large party and we were seated not long after. It was an seasonably cold and blustery evening with wet snowflakes mixed in with the cold rain drops and Italian food was going to be a wonderful thing that evening. I only hoped for the best when we were all seated.
Via Arenello features a long and narrow dining area with a large bar area off to the side in the middle. Opposite the bar are a number of tables with banquette seating along the wall.
The long bar was accented with blue lights underneath and on the back bar area. They had a good selection of craft beers, they featured a full bar with a number of mixed drinks, and they also had a good wine list.
The menu at Via Arenella features a number of traditional Italian favorites including fettuccine alfredo, lasagna, and penne pasta in a classic bolognese sauce. They also had a number of house pasta specialties including prosciutto-stuffed tortellini in a cream sauce, linguine with fresh mussels, and the Bolognese Bianco - paccheri pasta topped with a Neapolitan white bolognese meat sauce along with with melted mozzarella cheese. They also had a number of chicken entrees, and a number of veal entrees to choose from to.
Our server for the evening turned out to be Rose Longobardi who was pleasant, efficient, and very informative of the items on the menu. For someone who wanted to slow down after owning a restaurant with her husband for a number of years, Rose certainly appeared to be in her element waiting on our table. She was thoroughly impressed that many of the people in our party were French Canadians, but we also had guys in from Washington State, Oregon and, of course, Iowa. When she asked me how I found the place, I told her that it was a stab in the dark via Yelp and Open Table. "You made a good choice," she told me as she patted me on the shoulder. "We'll take good care of you."
It turned out that all three of her sons and her husband were on duty that evening - Franco was bartending, Fonzo and Mario, Sr. were cooking the food, while Mario, Jr. was making pizzas. Rose did a good job of convincing me to try their pizza at some point, but I was in the mood for pasta that evening.
After some great appetizers - grilled octopus and fried calamari - and a house salad consisting of fresh greens with chopped tomatoes, sliced red onions and cucumbers, and Kalamata olives topped with a balsamic vinaigrette, our main entrees made it to the table. I have to admit I've been on a meat-filled ravioli kick as of late and that's what I got at Via Arenella that evening. It came in a wonderful sweat and tangy marinara sauce and I asked Rose if I could get a couple meatballs to go with it. Well, the meatballs were huge! One of my colleagues said, "Those aren't meat balls, they're bowling balls!" The meat-filled pasta, I could tell, was recently made in house with a nice ground beef and veal mixture. The meatballs were also a mix and they were some of the best meatballs I've ever had. I was more than happy with what I ordered.
My boss was gracious enough to ask my wife to join us for dinner that evening. She had come in to stay with me and to go shopping while I was working the show. She ordered the veal piccata with a side of fettuccine alfredo. When Rose sat the veal dish down in front of her, my wife's eyes bugged out. The veal was swimming in a wonderful cream lemon sauce with boatloads of sautéed mushrooms on top. My wife has just recently gotten to the point where she can eat fresh sautéed mushrooms after a lifetime of hating mushrooms, but even this was a little too much for her. I had a bite of her veal along with the mushrooms and it was sensational in flavor.
A number of the people got the special that evening - a pasta entree that featured fresh lobster in a light lemon sauce topped with capers. From the reviews from everyone who had it, it was out of this world in taste. But it was so rich that not one person who ordered the entree could finish it. Portions were definitely huge at Via Arenella.
A couple of my colleagues went with the spaghetti pescatore - spaghetti pasta mixed with clams, mussels, calamari and shrimp in a crushed plum tomato sauce that was very chunky. It, too, was a large portion and while they both did their best to finish up the delicious seafood pasta dish, there was a lot leftover when they finally threw in the towel.
One of my colleagues at the other end of the table got the gnocchi in the creamy vodka tomato sauce. He, too, thought it was just outstanding. And one of my other colleagues seated near me got the chicken parmigiana with a side of the fettuccine alfredo. He ate about half of the chicken parm and made a dent in the rich fettuccine. By the looks of satiation on everyone's faces, I think I hit a home run in terms of picking out Via Arenella for our dinner spot that evening.
(The next day, I told one of my dealers from St. Louis about Via Arenella and how good the food was. That night, he and a couple of his co-workers went there for dinner and one of them had the lobster pasta special. He had the same reaction as my colleagues had with their lobster pasta special the night before, "Oh my God! It was so great, but, oh, so rich!"
My wife and a friend of hers went to Via Arenella when they were in Chicago for a long weekend not long ago and they happened to have the lobster pasta special that night. My wife got it and she thought it was heavenly. But there was no way that she could take the leftovers back to the hotel. Even if she took it directly home and put it in the fridge, it wouldn't heat up properly to make it taste as good as it is served fresh at the restaurant.)
As I said, Rose did a wonderful job in talking up her son's pizza making prowess. I had to come back at some point later on after my first visit to try one of their pizzas. Seated at the bar this time, I ordered a small (10") thin-crust pizza. (They also had New York-style with thick crust edges, a Chicago deep-dish pizza, and a stuffed pizza that is similar to a large calzone at Via Aranella.) I got a Revolution Brewing Anti-Hero IPA to go along with my pizza. It was cut in tavern-style squares and featured thick chunks of Italian sausage, slices of salty pepperoni, and sliced fresh mushrooms in a tangy pizza sauce topped with mozzarella cheese. The crust was thin, but it was light and chewy. Rose was certainly correct - this was an excellent pizza.
Our initial visit to Via Arenella was outstanding. The taste of the food, the size of the portions, the friendly and efficient service by Rose Longobardi left everyone in my party of 12 with a satisfied - and full - feeling as we were leaving. My subsequent trip back to Via Arenella to try their pizza was equally as pleasurable. Although it is run by the Longobardi's sons, there is still that "mom and pop" feeling to the place. This was one of the more memorable places I've come across in my travels and I will definitely be back there for more of their great food at some point.
(Update - Via Arenella closed their doors at the end of September of 2019.)