I first started traveling on the road in the mid-80's working for a company out of Kansas City. Now, I had been to Kansas City many times previously because I had a girlfriend who lived there for a number of years before distance just made it too hard for us to stay together. But during my trips to see her during our time together, I was too young and culinarily naive to realize that Kansas City had an outstanding barbecue scene. On my first trip to Kansas City working for my new company in the mid-80's, my boss and his wife treated me to a meal at the Jack Stack Barbecue in Martin City, MO. It was the first of what would be many meals I've had at the original Jack Stack location. Over the years, Jack Stack has expanded to five locations around the greater Kansas City area. Staying in downtown Kansas City for a couple days recently, I found that I was walking distance from my hotel to the Jack Stack location in the old Freight House. I decided to head over there for dinner on a cool and somewhat rainy evening.
Years ago before I found a format or a voice for this blog, I had a couple small posts on the Jack Stack location in Martin City, which was actually called the Smoke Stack when I first went there in the mid-80's. But the constant through the history of the Smoke Stack - and then later on with what became Jack Stack - is the Fiorella family.
Russ Fiorella was one of 14 children who grew up in an Italian neighborhood in Kansas City. His parents, Italian immigrants, were originally farmers on the far east side of Kansas City until they were forced to find another line of work when farm prices fell in the 1930's. Like many of his brothers, Russ ended up running a small neighborhood grocery store and worked as the butcher. Russ loved to barbecue the meats he cut, and nearly every Sunday you'd find him smoking brisket, ribs, or pork shoulders for the Fiorella family.
Pictured right - Russ Fiorella standing in front of his neighborhood grocery store/butcher shop. Photo courtesy Jack Stack Barbecue.
As larger grocery stores started to take over, Russ knew that his little neighborhood grocery store couldn't survive. The story goes that Russ took his wife, Flora, to the hospital to give birth to the couples' sixth child. Instead of hanging around the hospital, Russ went over to a small roadhouse on the south side of Kansas City called The Lucky Inn and bought the place. The purchase surprised everyone around Russ, including Flora who had no idea he was even thinking about owning his own restaurant. Russ turned The Lucky Inn from a roadhouse tavern into a barbecue place and named it Smoke Stack BBQ.
The only hitch was that in order to buy The Lucky Inn, Russ Fiorella had to sell the family's seven bedroom, seven bathroom home and move the family - three boys and three girls - into the small apartment above the restaurant. But business started going well for the Fiorella's and by the time the seventh child came into the world around 1963, Russ was able to move the family to a larger home.
A fire destroyed the building in 1966, but the Fiorella's rebuilt and it wasn't long before business started to come back from the devastating fire. By the early 70's, three of Russ' children opened their own Smoke Stack locations around Kansas City with Russ' help, with oldest son Jack opening his place in Martin City, a small town on the far south side of Kansas City just inside the Missouri state line with Kansas.
Jack's location was next door to the famous Jess & Jim's Steakhouse - a destination restaurant that has garnered international fame over the years (and, as a personal side note, I think is overrated) - and that certainly didn't hurt his initial presence in the area. In fact, the location was such a huge success that Jack Fiorella and his wife, Delores, moved to its present day location at 135th and Holmes Road in 1978.
Pictured left - Jack Fiorella. Photo courtesy the Fiorella family and the Martin City Telegraph.
With business up and going at his barbecue place, Jack Fiorella soon opened a second restaurant in Overland Park, KS called Hatfield and McCoys that offered some of the barbecue items that the Smoke Stack restaurants had along with an expanded menu. However, tough economic times in the early 80's forced the closure of that restaurant. In the meantime, Jack had neglected the Martin City barbecue location enough that business was down and they weren't even open for lunch any longer. Crestfallen by his failure at another restaurant and over a half million dollars in debt, Jack directed all his efforts to his barbecue restaurant in Martin City. He came back to the restaurant full time with a small sign outside the restaurant that simply said, "Jack's Back!" People started to come back in droves to his barbecue place and within a couple of years he had paid off his debts from his failed restaurant.
Delores and Jack had always envisioned a more upscale barbecue restaurant compared to the other sit-down barbecue joints that were all over the Kansas City area. They had been one of the first barbecue places in the area to smoke meats with hickory wood after they opened in 1974, and Delores brought a woman's touch to the menu adding items such as seafood, chicken, lamb and steaks. They expanded the Martin City location putting in two additional dining rooms and it became just as popular of a destination restaurant as Jess & Jim's just down the road.
(Russ Fiorella passed away in 1986 and two of his daughters continued to run the original Smoke Stack location until 1999 when they closed the restaurant and the building was torn down soon thereafter. Flora Fiorella was still involved with the business up to the time that it closed and she passed away in 2008.)
By the mid-90's with an eye upon expansion, Jack and Delores had officially changed the name of their business to Fiorella's Jack Stack and opened a second Jack Stack restaurant in Overland Park in 1997. In 2000, a third Jack Stack opened in the renovated Freight House in Kansas City, and a fourth location opened in the Country Club Plaza area of Kansas City in 2006. In 2016, a fifth location in Lee's Summit, MO was opened. After eating at the one in the Freight House, I have now eaten at all five locations in the greater Kansas City area.
Jack and Delores Fiorella's son and daughter, Kevin and Jennifer, also helped in the business as it grew. Catering and private dining were introduced in the early 90's at a facility just down the street from the Martin City Jack Stack, and by 2000 the company had started a mail order business to ship ribs, burnt ends and other barbecued meats around the United States. In 2009, Jack and Delores retired selling the company to their daughter Jennifer and her husband Case Dorman who is the CEO of the Jack Stack empire today. A fourth generation Fiorella family member, Case and Jennifer's son Keaton, works in the catering department for Jack Stack.
The Freight House in Kansas City is located in the Crossroads Art District, a collection of unique boutiques, restaurants, studios and art galleries on the south end of Kansas City's downtown area. Originally built in the late 1880's, it was used for storage of freight and dry goods that came in on dozens of trains that stopped in Kansas City each day. As the advent of truck freight and outlying warehouses came into being in the 1950's, the Freight House began to see a significant drop in usage. By the 1980's, it was all but closed down and fell into disrepair.
In 1995, a group of investors bought the dilapidated property and began a three year process of repurposing the building into usable space. The owners envisioned three restaurants in the space. Celebrity chef Lidia Bastianich opened the first restaurant, the eponymously named Lidia's, in 1998. The Fiorella family opened Jack Stack in 2000, and a restaurant by the name of City Market opened in 2003. City Market closed in 2010 and was replaced soon thereafter by Grunauer, an Austrian/German restaurant owned by famed chef Peter Grunauer. (Look for an upcoming post on Grunauer at some point in the near future.)
As I said, it was a very short walk - less than five minutes - from my hotel to the Jack Stack BBQ location in the Freight House. (see map). I had never been to that location and as I walked through a vehicle entry way between Lidia's and Grunauer, I walked into a large parking lot that faced Union Station just across the multitude of tracks between that and the Freight House. It was sort of surprising to me that I had never been to this place in all the years I've been coming to Kansas City.
Since I was a single diner, I tried to get a seat in the bar area. But the bar was packed including the sit down areas. I went to the hostess stand to see if I could get a seat in the dining area. She sort of hesitated and said, "Well, we really don't have a booth at this time." I didn't think I heard her correctly and I looked out at the dining area and saw a sea of tables in the center of the room. I said, "I don't really need a booth." She looked at a four-seater table in the center of the room that was empty and asked if I could have that. She escorted me right there and dropped off a menu for me to look over.
The main dining room at the Freight House Jack Stack BBQ is pretty impressive. It's a long and narrow space with a vaulted ceiling with wood truss supports. From the supports were faux candle lighting hanging down above the middle of the dining area. The brick walls had pictures of trains that used to stop at the Freight House and Union Station. There was a large room toward the back of the dining area that could be used for private dining or large groups of up to about 20 people. A statue of the bull depicted in the Jack Stack logo was the centerpiece on the large table.
My server for the evening was a young lady by the name of Tara. She asked me what I would like to drink and I ordered up a Boulevard Pale Ale which is made less than a mile away from the Jack Stack at the Freight House. Then I settled in to take a look at the menu.
Actually, I've eaten at Jack Stack locations so much over the years that I really don't need a menu. The primary barbecue offerings haven't changed much over the years - pork ribs, lamb ribs, beef ribs, pulled pork, smoked chicken, burnt ends, brisket, as well as smoked ham, turkey and sausage are the barbecue staples of the place. They have a number of sandwiches to choose from with all their smoked meat offerings, as well as a grilled French dip sandwich made with sliced prime rib beef, and a chicken chipotle club sandwich. And, of course, since it is Kansas City, Jack Stack also offers hickory-grilled steaks, pork chops, and seafood entrees. One thing that I've been very tempted to try at some point is their hickory smoked prime rib. I'm guessing that just has to be outstanding.
But like always, I went with the combo barbecue platter. I got the three meat combo with sliced brisket, burnt ends, and pulled pork. Fries come with the meal, but you also get a choice of two sides. The hickory pit beans are always a must, and I really like their cole slaw at Jack Stack. The cole slaw is creamy with a somewhat sweet and somewhat spicy taste with a dash of paprika added.
They have two different types of sauces at Jack Stack, both are served warm. One is a conventional Kansas City sweet and smoky sauce, the other is a hotter sauce that has more of a peppery taste. They don't really emphasize the sauces at Jack Stack and that's OK because the meats are usually very good.
And on this visit, it was not exception to the rule. The pulled pork literally melted in my mouth with each bite. The brisket was tender, lean and full of a great smoky beef flavor. And the burnt ends were done to perfection - large, chunky and tender. I've had some pretty suspect burnt ends around Kansas City over the years, but the ones at Jack Stack have consistently been very good over the years.
The visit to the Freight House Jack Stack BBQ completed my scorecard of eating at all five locations in the Kansas City area. A lot of barbecue places have popped up in the Kansas City area over past twenty years that have tried to emulate the Fiorella family's success in the quality of their meats, the foods other than barbecue that they offer, and the more upscale dining settings that have long defined what Jack Stack is all about. I know there's a lot of choices for barbecue in Kansas City - and I will say that there are a couple three that I may like better than Jack Stack. But if you're going to Kansas City and looking for a starting point where to try barbecue for the first time, I would say start at Jack Stack BBQ and go from there. The consistent quality of the barbecue is one of the reasons why I keep going back time and time again.