My wife has a December birthday close to Christmas. When it falls on or near a weekend, we usually go into Chicago to celebrate. (Well, even if it's in mid-week, we'll still go into Chicago for a couple three days to celebrate.) But, of course, not this year. And being that her birthday was on a Saturday this year, it was difficult to find a local restaurant that was A) a nice place; and B) had seats available for dining in the evening. With restrictions in place, most of the good restaurants in the Quad Cities were either closed (Illinois side) or down to 50% capacity (Iowa side).
We decided to sort of wing it on dinner that night and we started out with mid-afternoon drinks at R Bar, a small wine bar/martini bar that my wife likes to go to from time to time. We were talking with Rochelle, one one of the bartenders there, and she was coming up with different ideas of where we could go to dinner. Then she said, "Have you guys tried Monarch yet?" We said, no - in fact, we had never heard of the place. She said, "Oh, it's this great place that just opened near the Davenport/Bettendorf border on E. 53rd." The more she got to talking about the place, the more we wanted to go.
I called to make reservations, but I was told by the person at Monarch Kitchen + Bar that they were sold out for seating in the restaurant for the evening. "But, we have high-top tables in the bar area and you can sit at the bar and have dinner, if you like," she explained. "It's first-come, first-serve in the bar area." It was getting to be just past 5 p.m. when we decided to head over to Monarch and check the place out.
Monarch Kitchen + Bar is just north of 53rd near Falcon Ave. and you have to take one of the side streets off 53rd to get into their parking lot. (see map) The building sort of sits at an angle and people driving eastbound on 53rd have a better view of the front of the restaurant than those heading west. We had just driven by the place - heading westbound - the night before and realized that we had probably driven past Monarch at least a half-dozen times since it had a soft-opening in October. And they were still in their soft-opening phase the night we were there so we were able to snag a high-top table in the bar area.
The bar area is sort of tucked back in a corner of the restaurant and features a three-sided bar with a full bar back. Martini's seemed to be their specialty and the 3 bartenders were scurrying around mixing drinks for patrons. Above the bar area was a floral-patterned acoustic tile that hung down from the ceiling. They had a couple three more around the restaurant to really keep the noise in Monarch to a dull roar. It wasn't obtrusive, but the background noise was still notable.
The highlight of the bar area is the infinity fireplace that stands between the bar and the dining area of Monarch. Only it's not a real fireplace - it's cool water vapor that comes up from the grates and is illuminated by 3 different colors of LED lights. The stone facade held a shelf for people to stand near the vapor "flames" and have a drink. It was actually kind of cool looking.
Our server that evening was a personable and fun young lady by the name of Jamie. Dressed in the Monarch Kitchen + Bar's staff's standard mode o' day navy blue and white gingham shirt, Jamie was also one of the bartenders at Monarch. She asked us if we had been to Monarch before. "I hadn't even heard of the place until about an hour ago," I told her.
We had our menus in place and she was going through the menu to talk about some of the items. Many of the foods they serve are locally-sourced and everything is made from scratch in the kitchen. She pointed out the burger they had on the menu and I said, "Oh, yeah. I saw one go by our table a few moments ago. It looked good!"
"It's great," Jamie said excitedly. "When our chef was in Arizona, he got a Top 5 national award for his burger..."
I said, "Hold it. The chef is from Arizona?"
"Yeah," she said. "He came here a few years back because his wife was from here."
"And he was going to open a restaurant down at the Freight House or the old depot in downtown Davenport," I said in a questioning manner.
"That's him," Jamie replied. "Do you know the chef?"
Well, no - we didn't know the chef, but we definitely knew of him from a conversation I had with one of my sisters over four years ago. And here's that back story -
My two oldest sisters live in the Phoenix area. My oldest sister and her husband are fine food enthusiasts like my wife and I, but my brother-in-law's world travels have taken them to some very fine restaurants. When I was at their house in Scottsdale in December of last year, they were showing me the collection of menus from some of the more memorable restaurants that they had matted and framed to hang on their wall in a hallway between two bedrooms. I was immediately jealous and also smacking my head thinking of some of the more memorable places we had been to over the past 25 years where we could have easily asked for a menu to do exactly the same thing my sister and brother-in-law had done.
One of their favorite restaurants in Phoenix is a little bistro/tavern/wine store by the name of Tarbell's on E. Camelback Road. They casually knew Tarbell's chef/food and beverage manager Matt Fenton from their visits there after they had moved down a few years ago from Louisville. One day a little over four years ago, Fenton told my sister and brother-in-law that he was moving to the Quad Cities to open up a restaurant in an old train depot in downtown Davenport. As I said, his wife was from Bettendorf and they wanted to be closer to her family back in Iowa. My sister was excited to tell me about Matt Fenton's new venture in the Quad Cities and we had to check it out when he opened.
The problem was, however, he never opened. In the summer of 2017, there was talk of two new restaurants going into the old Union Station building across the tracks from LeClaire Park in downtown Davenport. However, a few days before work was to begin on the project, Fenton pulled out of the venture. (One of the spaces eventually became the home to Taste of Ethiopia. Click here to see the Road Tips entry on Taste of Ethiopia.)
My sister had asked me a couple years ago if anything ever came about with Fenton's restaurant in Davenport. I told her that I don't know what happened and I didn't know if he even stuck around the Quad Cities. But, as it turned out, Matt Fenton was, indeed, the chef/proprietor of Monarch.
Matt Fenton was always fascinated by cooking. As a young boy, he took cooking classes at a local public library, then continued to learn how to cook through his high school years. Working through an organization called Careers Through Culinary Arts Program, Fenton earned a scholarship at Johnson & Wales University, a college known for their culinary arts program. After graduating with a degree in Food Management Service, Fenton worked in restaurants in the Denver area before moving to Phoenix to work with chef Mark Tarbell who Fenton considers his biggest mentor. Tarbell, a Paris-trained chef, moved to Phoenix when he was 23 and was the youngest food and beverage director at any 5-diamond resort in the world. In 2007, Tarbell also gained notoriety as the champion chef on the Food Network's Iron Chef America show. While working with Tarbell, Fenton had the opportunity to prepare a meal at the James Beard Foundation house in New York City, an honor for any chef or restaurant.
While working at Tarbell's, Fenton also became an accredited sommelier through the Court of Master Sommeliers, a Napa Valley-based organization that focuses on educating members on the intricacies of wine. Fenton found that he had as much a passion with wine as he did with food from his years of culinary studies and mentorships.
Pictured right - Matt Fenton. Photo courtesy Monarch Kitchen + Bar Facebook page
After the restaurant venture at the old Union Station in Davenport fell through, Fenton kept busy doing a number of different things in the Quad Cities. He did catered events for private parties and organizations, he helped out as a brewer's assistant at Bent River Brewing Company over in Moline, and he worked on Sundays as an omelet chef at the Hyatt Place hotel part of The Bend complex in East Moline. Things started to come together on his dream of opening his own restaurant late last year and finishing touches were put on the restaurant in early October. There's been no mention locally in the press or on TV about Monarch's opening and all of their business so far has come from social media or word-of-mouth - sort of how we found out about the place.
Well, all hell broke lose when we told Jamie that we knew of Matt Fenton's work at Tarbell's in Phoenix. It wasn't more than about five minutes later that Fenton appeared at our table and said, "I heard you've eaten at Tarbell's in Phoenix." I had to explain to him that we hadn't, but my two sisters and my brother-in-law had and had told us that he was moving to the Quad's over four years ago. "Yeah, that was supposed to be two restaurants in the old depot downtown," he said. "Sort of glad that it never happened down there with all the flooding they've had the past couple of years."
I jokingly said, "And instead, you decide to open during a pandemic."
He sort of laughed and said, "Yeah, well, the wheels were turning with this place long before we knew there was going to be a pandemic." He looked around at the rapidly filling restaurant and said, "But it hasn't turned out too bad..."
After Matt thanked us for coming in, he went back to the kitchen. On the hallway to the restrooms, you could look through glass plate windows directly into the open kitchen area. It was a beehive of activity with Matt Fenton and his kitchen crew cranking out meals for patrons on a Saturday evening.
The main dining area isn't all that large, but it features a handful of booths including three large booths with curved high-backs along the far end of the restaurant. Tables with banquette seating were along the other window wall with tables and booths finishing out the dining area. It was sort of chic modern decor with some interesting artwork on display in the bar and dining area. There is also a private dining room off to the side of the main dining room at Monarch. Streamline Architects of East Moline - who is quickly getting a reputation for some unique designs in restaurants in the area - were the designers of the lay-out of Monarch Kitchen + Bar.
My wife and I ordered drinks while we checked out the menu. She had had a couple three martinis at the R Bar before we came over and she was feeling no pain. She ordered a cosmopolitan from Jamie while I ordered up a Pseudo Sue from the Toppling Goliath brewery up in Decorah, IA.
The menu wasn't vast, and I was sort of happy to see that. They had a number of interesting items including some pasta dishes, a roasted chicken entrée, grilled salmon, pan-roasted walleye, and a Ramen-style bowl of noodles that featured assorted pickled vegetables, sliced soft-boiled eggs and a house-made ponzu sauce. You could also add grilled chicken, shrimp, or salmon to the noodles for an uncharge. In addition to the main entrees, Monarch also featured a few salads - protein could be added to the salads - and a beef Wellington for 2 could be ordered with a two-day notice. And they even had caviar on the menu! Don't know if I've seen caviar on a menu in the Quad Cities area before. And nearly all the items on the menu were listed as gluten free.
They also had a number of interesting shareable appetizers on the menu at Monarch Kitchen + Bar. My wife was interested in the house-made hummus, while the "Better Than Prime Beef" carpaccio caught my eye. Spicy Thai chicken lettuce wraps and hand-pulled mozzarella stuffed with lemon ricotta, cured tomato and pesto, and served with pieces of crostini.
But there was one thing on the appetizer part of the menu that I had to try - the spicy tuna tartar. It was made with sushi grade tuna placed on top of a piece of deep-fried sticky rice, then topped with an apple ponzu sauce and seaweed salad with a spicy aioli drizzled around it. Oh - my - GOD!! It was unbelievably tasty. The tuna was tender and flavorful, and the spicy aioli wasn't all that spicy to my taste. I told my wife that I could eat three of the spicy tuna tartar and I'd be a happy guy for dinner.
For our entrées that evening, my wife was torn between three things - two of which were the lobster and gnocchi that came with locally-grown oyster mushrooms; and the roast leg of lamb which came with garlic mashed potatoes and roasted locally-grown root vegetables. At first, she did order the lamb, but then had a change of heart because she wanted steak for her birthday dinner. She changed her mind to the filet and crab - a six ounce Iowa tender beef filet with fresh lump crab meat. Buttermilk-mashed potatoes with demi-glace and creamed spinach came with the steak and crab meat.
I was torn between the pork and beef ragu with house-made Pappardelle pasta, or the oyster mushroom Tagliatelle in a garlic cream sauce. Jamie said, "Oh, the ragu is excellent. I would take that over the Tagliatelle. I took her recommendation.
I also wanted to get a glass of cabernet for dinner. They had two - the Broadside cabernet and the Justin cab, both from the Paso Robles area in California. Jamie said, "The Broadside is five dollars cheaper by the glass, but I like the body and richness in the Broadside better." Since I wasn't overly familiar with either one, I took her recommendation once again. My wife got a glass of the Pascual Toso reserva malbec from Argentina.
Another waiter brought our meals out and they looked delicious. As we were getting settled, my wife realized that she didn't have a steak knife. She was just turning to see if she could get someone's attention, Jamie came over to the table with a silver platter of assorted steak knives on a napkin. "We offer our customers their choice of steak knives," she said. "It's kind of a neat little thing we do here at Monarch." My wife picked out a pearl-handled steak knife. Jamie remarked, "It sort of reminds me of a French folding knife." I've been presented with steak knives in wooden boxes at restaurants before, but nearly all the steak knives were different at Monarch. It was a nice little touch in presentation, I thought.
My wife was a bit apprehensive when she cut into the steak. She had ordered the steak medium, but the first bite was well overdone. However, I took a look at the steak and it was misshapen, and she had cut into the tip of the steak. "I'm guessing that once you get to the other end, it will be fine" She turned her plate to cut into the fatter end of the steak and it turned out to be a perfect medium, still pink and juicy in the middle.
The steak came with five or six chunks of crab meat that swam in the demi-glace. The steak rested on a bed of spinach and my wife remarked that there were a lot of excellent flavors going on all at once with each bite. "This is perfect," she said, fully happy with what she ordered.
My beef and pork ragu turned out to be a hearty and wonderful Italian comfort meal. Jamie told me when she came over to check on us that the meal normally didn't come with crostini bread, but she had them put some on the plate because "that's how I like it," she explained. "I like to clean the sauce out of the bottom of the bowl with bread." She had been spot on with her recommendations all night long and the bread sopping up the thick and meaty ragu after the wide-cut Pappardelle noodles were gone was a perfect ending to the meal.
And she was spot on with our wine, as well. The Broadside cabernet was bold, full-bodied, sort of a spicy black pepper to the taste, and went great with my meal. This is what could have easily been called an Italian comfort meal. My wife was happy with her malbec, as well. A few of the wines on the wine list I was familiar with, but there were some interesting red blends and some New Zealand sauvignon blancs that I wanted to learn about. I made a mental note to try and find some of the Broadside cabernet for our home collection.
The meals we had featured generous portions, but not enough where we felt completely full or bloated after we finished. And since it was my wife's birthday, we had to get dessert for her. Jamie gave us a dessert menu and they also had their whiskey and cordial menu on it. I took a look at their single malt scotch list and sort of cringed at some of the prices. I told Jamie when she came back to take our dessert order that I was thinking of getting a scotch, but I was sort of alarmed at the prices. The cheapest scotch was 15 bucks. "That's five dollars higher than what I can get the same drink for at a lot of places around town."
Jamie said, "OK, well, we pour a generous drink here. Most places will pour two fingers, we go two-and-a-half to three fingers." She still couldn't convince me, and besides, we were going for a nightcap at a new bar and restaurant in downtown Davenport that was having a soft opening that night and we were told by friends of ours who are co-owners of the place to go check it out.
Just like the food menu, the dessert menu at Monarch Kitchen + Bar is pretty compact. They had a crème brûlée that immediately caught our attention. There was a "decadent" chocolate mousse on the menu, as well an apple crisp served with cinnamon ice cream. My wife was waffling between the chocolate mousse and something called "Chef Emma's EVOO Cake" that came with whipped lemon curd.
Jamie came back and we told her of my wife's quandary. "She can't decide between the extra virgin olive oil cake or the chocolate mousse."
Jamie perked up and said, "Hey, that's good! Most people don't know that EVOO stands for extra virgin olive oil. I've had people order the 'EEE-vuuu' cake before." We got a laugh out of that one.
My wife first ordered the chocolate mousse, but ended up changing her mind to the EVOO cake with the whipped lemon curd after I had ordered my dessert. She was happy with it, but she said she wished she would have gotten the chocolate mousse instead. I tried a bite of the cake with some of the lemon curd and I thought it was delicious. I told her that we could always come back and get the chocolate mousse on our next visit.
All night long, Jamie had been giving me excellent recommendations and I said, "Well, you haven't gone wrong on the beef and pork ragu, and you certainly didn't go wrong with the win. What do you recommend for dessert." She immediately said to get the cheesecake with the salted caramel sauce. They make the cheesecake in-house at Monarch and she said it was her favorite dessert on the menu. And, once again, she didn't steer me wrong. The cheesecake was rich and savory, and the salted caramel sauce gave it even more of a sweet and succulent taste. It wasn't a big piece of cheesecake, but it didn't need to be. It was so filling and sinfully good, even in a small portion.
For completely winging it on my wife's birthday this year, we were amazed at how well things turned out by going to Monarch Kitchen + Bar on a whim from a recommendation we got earlier in the day. And it was rather serendipitous that chef Matt Fenton was the guy my sister and brother-in-law knew in Phoenix who they told us was moving to the Quad Cities over four years ago and to be on the lookout for his new restaurant. It took some time for him to settle in to get his new restaurant, but the wait was worth it. I'd have to say that we loved everything about our first visit to Monarch - the food was excellent, the staff was very friendly and accommodating, Jamie did a great job with her food and wine recommendations, and we got a chance to meet Matt Fenton who came out to our table to talk with us. The burger at Monarch Kitchen + Bar intrigues me very much and I can't wait to get back out there to give it a try in the very near future. But Monarch has just jumped to the top of our list for special occasion meals in our family.