My wife and I were recently invited for a weekend retreat to my sister's fiancé's lake home along Lake Panorama in west central Iowa. My sister's fiancé and I were working out dinner plans in advance and he was giving me some options in the area where we could go. One place that he suggested was a place in the small town of Paton, IA that I had heard about in the past and had wanted to try since first hearing about it. We agreed that we needed to go have a meal at 209 Main one of the nights we would be at the lake.
Vaughn Bauer is what you would call a modern success story. Bauer grew up in a farm family outside of Paton and went to a local community college to study welding and metal machining. After getting his certificate in 1977, Bauer set up his first shop - Paton Machine and Welding - that he ran in conjunction with working part-time on the family farm. At the time, jobs were tight and the Bauer family would do what they had to do to make a living.
As Vaughn Bauer sat on a tractor planting corn or beans in the Iowa soil, his mind would wander to figuring out how to make a better planter, something that would plant wider than the usual 12 rows planters of the day would allow. In the early 80's, he came up with a toolbar that would allow planter wings on a standard 12 row John Deere planter that could be easily placed in an upright position for easy transport. Soon, Bauer would modify other planters for friends and farmers in the area.
By 1989, Bauer had started to manufacture his own multi-row planters. He called his company Bauer Built and his planters started gaining the attention of farmers across America and internationally, alike. By 1995, he had redesigned the tool bar on the front of his planters to accommodate more planting boxes that would eventually allow up to 48 rows being planted at once.
In 2002, John Deere started a co-branding agreement with Bauer Built to sell Deere-Bauer planters around the world. A few years later, Deere ended up buying out Bauer Built taking over the 150-employee plant in 2013. Today, Bauer Built has a manufacturing facility just down the road from the original plant that Deere now runs. Vaughn Bauer employs 60 people that work on special projects for John Deere. In addition to collaborating with Deere, Bauer Built also manufactures sleds that are used worldwide for tractor pulls, a hobby Vaughn Bauer and his family has been involved in since he was a teenager.
With so many interested parties coming to Paton to check out the Bauer Built planters - many from countries outside of the US - there was no place for Vaughn Bauer and his wife Lori to entertain clients. Paton is a very small town with a population less than 200 people. The town didn't even have a convenience store until the Bauer's put one in a number of years ago. It became evident that the Bauers were going to have to do something on their own to provide a place where they could entertain clients coming into Paton.
The Bauers came up with a concept of a steak house-style restaurant that had a nice bar area and a reception/banquet area for larger parties. Work started on the building in the downtown area of Paton in 2012 and in 2013 along about the time they sold Bauer Built to John Deere, the Bauers opened 209 Main for business. (The Bauers also own 716 Main in Humboldt, IA, the second of what they hope will be many similar restaurants they hope to bring to small towns in Iowa.)
It was a 45 minute drive from Lake Panorama up to Paton. After a quick stop at the Wild Rose Casino in Jefferson, IA to bet horses in the Kentucky Derby, we ended up in front of 209 Main around 5:30 p.m. (See map) There was a class reunion going on in the banquet hall of 209 Main, but seating was plenty in both the dining room and in the bar, known as the Tool Bar.
The Tool Bar at 209 Main is to the left as you walk in the front door. Multiple flat-screen televisions hang from the walls and around the rectangular bar. Above the entrance to the restrooms for the restaurant/bar is a Harley-Davidson motorcycle just sitting there. I've never understood the reasoning why some places will have what appears to be a perfectly good motorcycle on display. It could be that it was Vaughn Bauer's and his wife didn't want him to ride it any longer.
The bar, itself, garnered a reputation for its chill strips - basically, a narrow cooling strip along the edge of the bar where patrons could put their beers or drinks to maintain a cold temperature. The only other place that I've seen this was at the Maui Brewing Company when we had lunch there a number of years ago. (Click here to see the Road Tips entry on the Maui Brewing Company.) The only problem is that the chill strips at the Tool Bar were deactivated. All I know is that chill strips wouldn't help me out - I drink my beers too quickly.
We found a table in the bar area - there were five of us as my sister's fiancé's son joined us for dinner. Our server that evening was a nice young lady by the name of Courtney. After she gave us our menus, we ordered up some drinks. They had a hazy IPA from the Lake Time Brewery out of Clear Lake, IA on tap - the G-Haze Lives. We had been to the Lake Time Brewery before and I sort of remember getting that when we were there.
The menu featured a little bit of a lot of things - steaks, seafood, pasta dishes, pork chops, burgers, sandwiches and even down-home Iowa comfort food staples like an open-faced hot beef sandwich, and a hand-battered fried chicken breast served with mashed potatoes and a creamy pepper gravy. That actually sounded pretty good to me. 209 Main also had pizza on their menu and I understand that it's pretty good.
We started out with some appetizers for the table - boneless chicken wings, a bacon-cheese dip that was served with toasted bread, and the 209 poutine consisting of French fries topped with cheese curds, shredded braised beef, chopped green onions and cheddar cheese finished with a rich demi-glaze sauce over the top of the whole concoction. Now, THAT was delicious!
Interestingly, they had a salad bar at 209 Main. With restrictions in place for many restaurants during the pandemic, salad bars had gone by the wayside. I was pleasantly surprised to see a full salad bar up and running at 209 Main. It had the normal fixings - pickled beets, sliced mushrooms, cherry tomatoes, and other veggies to go with the lettuce greens. After putting a few things on my plate at the salad bar, I got back to the table and saw that my sister's fiancé had gotten a bowl of soup. It was a green chile soup and I asked where it was on the salad bar. "At the end," my sister told me. "You probably walked right by it." Well, my wife says that I'm not very observant and I certainly didn't see it. I went back to get a cup of the soup and I'm glad I did. It was very similar to some of the better green chile soups I've had during our visits to Colorado.
The salad bar was located in the main dining room. The dining area featured large tables for group dining as well as a number of booths along the wall. Laser-cut metal signs and parts made at Bauer Built hung from the walls of the dining area. Some of the signs were the names of countries that had hosted patrons at 209 Main during their visits to Paton over the years. The bar area was much more lively and I'm glad we sat in there rather than in the dining room.
They have prime rib after 5 p.m. on Friday and Saturday nights. Now, I had prime rib the night before at Prime Time in Guthrie Center (click here to see an earlier Road Tips entry on Prime Time), but for some reason I really wanted to try the prime rib at 209 Main. And I'm glad I did. It was a wonderful cut of prime beef, juicy and tender. I had asked Courtney to have the chef cut it as rare as possible and there was a lot of pink color throughout. It came with green beans on the side. I had a choice of potato and I got the au gratin potatoes. I had made my way through much of the prime rib before I threw in the towel and had to take a good chunk of it back with me. As much as I love beef, two large prime ribs on back-to-back nights was a little too much.
My wife and my sister's fiancé's son both got the ribeye that evening. My wife got the loaded baked potato for her potato choice. She was very happy with the flavor of the ribeye which she had cooked medium. Actually, my wife was even more impressed with the flavor and texture of the green beans. She said they weren't overcooked and had a good snap when cut. I didn't pay much attention to my green beans.
My sister went with ribeye steak sandwich - basically, the ribeye on a hoagie bun that's dressed out. And my sister's fiancé got the broasted chicken. It featured two pieces of chicken - he got a third one with a small upcharge - and came with the green beans and a choice of potato. He appeared to like it very much as there wasn't a lot of meat left on the bones when he finished.
I had heard good things about 209 Main and I certainly wasn't disappointed. Having a restaurant like this in a small town like Paton is interesting enough. 209 Main would fit in most anywhere in the Midwest. My prime rib was very good - one of the better cuts of prime rib that I've had in a long time - and my wife was very happy with her ribeye. Everyone in our party was more than satisfied with the choices they had for their dinner. On top of that, the salad bar was a nice surprise and the green chile soup they had on the salad bar rivaled some of the better green chile soups I've had in Colorado. Paton is definitely off the beaten path, but if you make it out that way, I'd definitely recommend a stop at 209 Main.