My wife and I were a little handcuffed when it came to our anniversary in 2022, mainly because I had been unemployed for a few months, but was getting ready to start a new job in the coming weeks. We really couldn't go anywhere - even though my wife had taken the week off as she has done many times over the years during the week of our anniversary. We both had been keen on a place that we'd heard about in the small town of Mount Vernon, IA that specialized in wood-fired pizzas made with locally sourced food items, as well as having an interesting wine list. We took a little road trip on the day of our anniversary and took the backroads around Eastern Iowa ending up in Mount Vernon late in the afternoon to have dinner at the Lincoln Winebar.
Actually, we had always wanted to go to the Lincoln Café, a destination restaurant that was started by Matt Steigerwald in 2000. Steigerwald - a native of Cincinnati who grew up in Raleigh, North Carolina - had an extensive background in culinary services working for a handful of restaurants as well as with James Beard Award-winning chef Ben Barker at the lauded (but now closed) Magnolia Grill in Durham, NC. While in the Raleigh-Durham area, Steigerwald's wife Michelle Mouton completed her doctorate in English and Critical Theory at the University of North Carolina. Dr. Mouton's first job with her doctorate degree was to come to Mount Vernon and teach at Cornell College.
Steigerwald realized that Mount Vernon had a dearth of destination restaurants that served sustainable foods - as in zero. Working with local farmers and food co-ops, Steigerwald came up with an idea for a restaurant where the menu would change seasonally upon availability of locally-raised food products. Steigerwald opened the Lincoln Cafè in 2000 and it was an immediate hit with food connoisseurs who drove miles to dine at the restaurant. Steigerwald was a three-time James Beard Award nominee for his work at the Lincoln Café.
Three doors down from the Lincoln Café was a small wine cafe by the name of Divine Wines. It opened about the same time that Steigerwald opened his restaurant in 2000. In 2006, the owners of Divine Wines were looking to sell their spot, and like many chefs Steigerwald was looking to do something a little different. When the opportunity to buy Divine Wines came up, he jumped on it renaming the place the Lincoln Winebar.
In 2013, Steigerwald closed the Lincoln Café to concentrate on a revamp of the Lincoln Winebar. (Ironically, one of the people who Steigerwald bought Divine Wines from - Rachel Sauter - reopened a restaurant in the old Lincoln Café spot and called it the Palisades Cafe after the nearby cliffs along the Cedar River in what is known as Palisades-Kepler State Park. Sauter sold the restaurant in 2016.)
About six years after Steigerwald purchased the Lincoln Winebar, it became home to a huge (6500 lb.) specially-made wood-fired brick pizza oven that was manufactured in Italy by renowned artisan Stephano Ferrara, a 3rd-generation Napoli craftsman who is now helped in the family business by his son Simone. The oven - which features Santa Maria bricks from Campania, Italy, and mortar from Mount Vesuvius - cost about $25,000 to build and it took 3 months for the oven to make it to Mount Vernon from Naples. The roof of Lincoln Winebar had to be removed for the oven to be lowered into the establishment via crane. Inlaid in the ceramic tiles above the opening of the oven is the Italian phrase Il Cibo E Importante - "Food is Important". The brick oven can reach temperatures of 900 to 950 degrees (F) and can cook pizzas in 60 to 90 seconds.
In September of 2014, Steigerwald sold the Lincoln Winebar to long-time employee Jesse Sauerbrei. Sauerbrei had a background in wine and beer distribution before joining Steigerwald at the Lincoln Café. Steigerwald went to head up the New Pioneer Food Co-op's kitchen in Cedar Rapids. (Steigerwald is now involved with Wilson's Orchard and Farm outside of Iowa City heading up the kitchen at the Rapid Creek Cidery.)
Under Sauerbrei, Lincoln Winebar started doing lunches featuring sandwiches, salads and soups. (They no longer do lunches at Lincoln Winebar.) In the late summer of 2018, Lincoln Winebar procured a mobile brick oven that they take to events, private parties, farmers markets and other venues around Eastern Iowa. And just a few weeks ago, Sauerbrei partnered with James Beard Award regional semi-finalist Aaron Hall from The Local Crumb in Mount Vernon to open a new pizza/bakery concept in Cedar Rapids by the name of Fancy's New York.
It was just before 5 p.m. when we pulled up in front of Lincoln Winebar at the corner of 1st St. West and 2nd Ave. NW in downtown Mount Vernon. (see map) We had tried to go to the restaurant before, only to learn that they are closed on Sundays. (They're closed Mondays, as well.)
We walked up a set of stairs and into the restaurant. The large pizza oven in the corner behind the counter was tough to miss. There was a small bar area off to the side opposite the pizza oven. Lincoln Winebar featured wooden floors and a Tuscan-style wallpaper scheme. My wife immediately noticed the sound dampening panels on the ceiling to help keep the restaurant from being an ear-splitting echo chamber when filled with people.
The place was void of people when we walked in and an outgoing woman by the name of Rachel greeted us as we came in. She told us that we could sit anywhere and we took a table near the front window. Parched from the road trip, I immediately ordered a Big Grove Easy Eddie Hazy IPA. My wife ordered a glass of the house cabernet.
The menu was on the wall near the pizza oven. It was basic with just a few appetizers and a handful of pizzas with featured toppings. They also had a few specials that day including Morel mushrooms with chives in a panna cream sauce (it was $24 bucks and there was a limit to just one per table); locally grown asparagus with 'nduja salami from River Bear Meats out of Denver, CO; and a nettles salad with cream, red onion, sweet peppers and Mahón Spanish cheese. (I had to look up to see what nettles were and it's a spring herb that is high in oxidants and Vitamin C, and is usually served in tea.)
Some of the other items on the appetizer part of the menu were breadsticks made in the brick oven, house-made meatballs with arugula in a tomato sauce with parmesan cheese, and a basic house salad made with locally sourced greens.
What we ended up getting to start out was the burrata cheese with 'nduja appetizer. It featured a dollop of excellent burrata mozzarella cheese (hard on the outside, gooey on the inside) with sort of a paté of the 'nduja salami in a chile oil along with sweet pepper rings, arugula and gremolata (parsley, garlic and lemon juice). It came with crackers and the taste sensations from all fronts were off the charts. We sort of laughed and said that we could have had a couple more plates like that and that would have been fine for dinner.
Since pizza was the only main item on the menu board, we decided to get a sausage and pepperoni pizza. More people had come into the place, but our was going to be the first pizza of the day. It didn't take long and Rachel was setting the pizza down in front of us. It looked delicious with some charring on the fringes with ample amounts of ground Italian sausage and pepperoni slices mixed with a tangy pizza sauce with fresh mozzarella.
The only problem was that it really didn't taste all that great. It was very burnt on the bottom of the pizza. I like a little bit of burnt caramelization of the cheese on pizza, but the crust had that very burnt taste. We both had a piece and thought, "Wow, this is really burned."
Rachel came over to check on us and she said, "How's the pizza?" I turned a slice over on the pan I asked if it was supposed to be this burned on the bottom. "Oh my gosh," she gushed. "Oh, no! That's really burnt!"
It wasn't long until Jesse Sauerbrei walked over to the table and looked at the pizza. "Oh, man. I'm so sorry, folks," he said. "We're going to get you guys another pizza."
As they were making up another pizza, Jesse Sauerbrei came back over to the table to explain what had happened. "I've got a new guy working the pizza oven," he said. "He was working our mobile pizza oven over the weekend and the floor of that oven doesn't get as hot as the floor on this oven. He was still thinking that the pizzas needed to stay in a little longer." Jesse also comped us on another beer and a glass of wine for our troubles. We insisted that it wasn't that big of deal, but he made sure that we got a new set of drinks on the house.
Moments later Rachel brought over a new pizza for us. This time, there was much less char on the bottom of the dough. And it was a much better pizza, too. The flavors were all very fresh and melded well together. The crust was crispy, but had a nice doughy texture to the bite. I remarked to my wife that a side of marinara sauce would have been perfect to dip the pizza crust into. (We found out later on from Rachel that the breadsticks they have come with a marinara dipping sauce. We'll be sure to get some marinara on the side for the pizza crust next time we make it back.)
For dessert, they have tiramisu on the menu. Only - that day - they didn't. Rachel apologized to us for the lack of tiramisu and we were sort of crestfallen with that revelation. But that didn't stop us - we went back to the Quad Cities and stopped at Biaggi's for a couple pieces of tiramisu to finish off our anniversary evening.
The first very burnt pizza would have had us probably not coming back had we not said something to our server when she came back to check on us. But they were very apologetic and accommodating in getting us a pizza that wasn't burned - and one that was very good. It was an excellent pizza where all the ingredients tasted fresh and flavorful. The service from Rachel was top-notch, and the atmosphere was cozy and welcoming. Mount Vernon is kind of a haul from the Quad Cities, so it's difficult for us to get back to the Lincoln Winebar as much as we'd like to. But for others willing to make the drive to Mount Vernon from Iowa City, Cedar Rapids or other points in Eastern Iowa, the pizza is worth it.