When I was in New York City, there was still a lot of college basketball to be played and I was hoping to be able to watch some of the Iowa women's basketball game one night. The University of Iowa I-Club has a number of chapters around the United States and I looked up on their web site to see if there were any Iowa game watch sites in New York City. It turned out that there was an Irish pub about 10 blocks from my hotel that was a game watch site. I would have walked to the restaurant, but it was spitting rain and rather cool out. So, I took an Uber down to The Playwright Irish Pub on W. 35th Street between 5th and 6th avenues in Manhattan. (see map)
Frank Dwyer was born and raised in County Leitrim in the northern part of Ireland. At the age of 19, he immigrated to the U.S. and settled in New York City working as a carpenter in building construction and renovations. For the next 20-plus years Dwyer worked on a number of bars and restaurants in various places across New York City. By the time he was in his early 40's, he decided that he'd rather run his own restaurant/pub that build them.
Dwyer had just finished building two pubs for Pete Fitzpatrick near Times Square - McGee's Pub and Connolly's. Dwyer let Fitzpatrick know that he was interested in having his own pub and the last restaurant he built for Fitzpatrick was going to be his first restaurant as a co-owner of a tavern/restaurant. In 1995, Fitzpatrick and Dwyer opened the first Playwright Tavern and Restaurant at the corner of W. 49th Street and 7th Avenue. Three years later, the two opened a second Playwright Tavern on 8th Avenue between 45th and 46th Streets.
From there, Dwyer and Fitzpatrick opened a number of other pubs and restaurants in New York - Jack Demsey's, McHale's, another Connolly's location, Legends, and Hurley's Saloon just to name a few. Dwyer and Fitzpatrick also own a hotel near Times Square, as well as restaurants/pubs in New Orleans and West Palm Beach, FL. And around the turn of the millennium, they opened their third Playwright Irish Pub on W. 35th St.
My Uber driver pulled up in front of the restaurant/pub with a red facade situated underneath a series of scaffolds that seem to be omnipresent in New York City. Walking into the bar, I found a two story facility with a packed downstairs bar area. It was definitely an Irish/sports bar with multiple televisions on the wall behind the bar.
In the back of the downstairs bar area was a smaller room with a low ceiling that was even more packed with Iowa fans getting ready to watch the Hawkeyes women's game. There was no place to sit and I didn't feel like standing for the next two-plus hours, especially if I wanted something to eat. I decided to check out the rest of the place.
I ended up heading upstairs and I found a large bar area with more televisions interspersed around the room. There was a nice dark wood bar along one wall with a number of tables and chairs along the opposite walls. It was much less crowded upstairs than down, and I ended up seated at the bar in front of a television set.
The bartender that evening was Michael - at least, that's what I thought he said it was. He had such a thick and genuine Irish brogue that it was sort of hard to understand him, especially with music by the likes of Republic of Loose, Måneskin and The Lumineers playing in the background. Michael - I'll call him that - gave me a food menu to look over and he started to change the televisions for the Iowa women's game coming on in a bit.
I ordered a Smithwick's on tap to start. It tasted flat, but I ended up drinking it. Later on, I got a Founders IPA on tap - and that tasted horrible. I was able to choke it down, but it was pretty bad. I've had the Founders IPA before and this one didn't taste close to the ones I've had. Then I got a Goose Island IPA draft - and THAT tasted bad. I finally said something to Michael and asked him if I could just get a Bud Light they had on tap. And the Bud Light tasted bad - not because it wasn't a craft beer, but because it just tasted weird. I figured out later on that they really needed to clean their lines out for the upstairs bar.
Another couple came and sat down by me. They were also from Iowa - from Altoona - and they were in New York for a long weekend. They also wanted to watch the Iowa game and they did the same thing as me - looked up to see where a watch site would be and found The Playwright. The lady ordered a Corona and her husband followed suit. I saw that they had a number of bottled beers in an enclosed cooler under the bar. I had already downed about the equivalent of 3 beers and I saw that they had Bud Light in bottles. I figured that if I was going to sit there and watch a game, I'd better go to a lighter beer.
We watched the Iowa women play - they won handily 95-62 over Penn State - and found that we had some friends in common since I grew up in Central Iowa and still had a bunch of friends there. They were good people to hang with while we watched the game.
After the game finished up, I decided I wanted to get something to eat before I went back to the hotel. It wasn't an extensive menu, but it had a number of appetizers, sandwiches, burgers, and salads available. I thought about getting the wings for a moment; the burgers sounded good, but I wasn't in the mood for a burger; and the filet mignon sandwich that sounded more like a Philly cheesesteak sandwich with carved beef tenderloin.
I got it down to one of two things - the pastrami and Swiss on rye, or the shepherd's pie. I ended up going with the shepherd's pie.
It was a traditional Irish casserole with a mixture of ground beef, peas, and carrots in a rich brown gravy topped by ropes of golden brown mashed potatoes on top. This was the real deal in terms of a shepherds pie. The dish was hearty and robust in taste. The mashed potatoes - it looked like they had been placed in a tube and pushed out into little squiggly ropes on top of the ground beef mixed with the veggies and gravy. This meal was a definite spot-hitter and more than made up for the crappy tasting beer they had on tap.
There are hundreds of Irish pubs in New York City, many of which are combination sports bars/Irish pubs. And the Playwright Irish Pub didn't really do much of anything to distinguish themselves from any of the other places. They really needed to clean out their beer lines going up to the second floor bar, but other than that it was a good place to hang out and watch an Iowa women's basketball game. The shepherd's pie was excellent and the service I had from Micheal was good. The Playwright Irish Pub was a good place to hang for a couple three hours watching sports and having some pretty good food.