When I was in New York for a trade show recently, I had made an appointment to go see one of our larger accounts in midtown Manhattan. Staying near Times Square, I determined that I could walk to the account - it was about 9 blocks away. On the way back from the appointment, I took a walk along W. 38th St. and decided that A) I was in need of warming up (it was 29 degrees that day); and B) I wouldn't mind grabbing a sandwich for lunch. I saw a place off in the distance that was a deli, but almost as soon as I saw that, I looked to my immediate right and saw a little pub that looked inviting. They had their menu out in front of the place and with the extensive craft beer menu they had listed, I decided to step into District Tap House to have some lunch.
Sean Marr was a native of Glasgow, Scotland and decided to get into the hospitality business in his late teens. After graduation with a degree in Hospitality Management from Napier University in Edinburgh, Scotland, Marr moved to the U.S. just before the turn of the century and worked in a number of restaurants in various capacities learning the ropes and creating a network of contacts in the restaurant industry in New York City.
In the early 2010's, Marr began to line up investors in a pub that he was looking to open in Midtown West in Manhattan. Along with four other investors, Marr opened District Tap House in 2014. He put Mike Geddes in charge as the managing partner of the restaurant while Marr and the investors opened two other pubs - Bedford Falls on E. 67th on the upper east side of Manhattan, and the now-closed District Social that was located a block south of District Tap House.
It was around 1:30 when I walked into District Tap House situated almost halfway between 8th Ave. and 7th Ave. on W. 38th Street in Manhattan's Midtown West/Garment District. (see map) I had to maneuver around the seemingly endless lanes of scaffolds that dot the sidewalks of the city in front of many buildings. I thought to myself that I'd love to run a scaffolding company in New York City because it seems like the city is incessantly working on their buildings.
Just inside District Tap House, the dark mahogany bar ran for about 40 feet along one wall. Globe light fixtures hung over the bar and flat screen televisions were spaced between shelves holding liquor on the back bar. Hightop tables were along a dark wood paneled wall opposite the bar. The place had a warm, comfy feeling - classy without any pretentiousness.
Toward the back of the long narrow pub past the bar were some community tables and booths. Just past the small dining area in the back was a partitioned area that looked like it could be used for private dining or gatherings. It was well past the lunch rush, so all the patrons in the place were seated at the bar. And that's where I plopped down to get some lunch.
The bartender/server was a sassy lady by the name of Rayleen. I remarked that I knew of only one other person in my life who had the name of Rayleen. "It's not a common one, that's for sure," she said in a thick Scottish brogue. "I only knew of one other Rayleen, a singer from Nova Scotia (the late Raylene Rankin). Except she spelled it different from how I spell it." I told Rayleen that the person I knew with the same name spelled it the same as hers.
Rayleen had dropped off a food menu and asked me what I wanted to drink. I asked if she had a drink menu and she sort of shook her head in disgust at herself. "This might help," she said as she placed a drink menu in front of me. They had over two dozen beers and ciders on tap and a like number of beers to choose from in bottles and cans. I saw that they had a Mighty Squirrel Cloud Candy hazy IPA that I had up in New England when I was up there last year. But they also had a local hazy IPA on tap - the Five Boroughs Gridlock - that I wanted to try. And it was an excellent hazy IPA.
The food menu at District Tap House wasn't all that extensive, but what they had was interesting. They had appetizers such as tuna tartar, goat cheese croquettes, wings, ground lamb sliders, and corn tortilla nachos with braised pork. Actually, they had a charred octopus appetizer with jalapeno chimichurri that I damned near ordered as my lunch.
Also on the menu at District Tap House was pizza with artisanal toppings; chicken, carne asada or fish tacos; soups; salads and sandwiches including a Cubano sandwich and a hanger steak sandwich with a horse radish cream and chimichurri.
It came down to three or four things - the charred octopus, the B.A.L.T. sandwich consisting of bacon, avocado, lettuce and tomato (very similar to how I make BLT's with avocado and basil at home), the District Burger, and the braised short rib sandwich. Actually, I pared it down to the charred octopus and the braised short rib sandwich. In the end, I went with the sandwich.
The sandwich featured slow-braised beef short rib that was pulled apart and placed on toasted ciabatta bread, then topped with Swiss cheese, a chipotle mayo and - interestingly enough - fried shaved carrots.
And the sandwich was excellent. The braised beef was tender and very flavorful on its own. The chipotle mayo and the Swiss cheese were great compliments to the taste of the beef. And the carrots added a bit of a crispy sweetness to the sandwich. The ciabatta bread had a crunchy outer shell and a chewy core. It didn't look big, but it was a hearty sandwich. Fries came on the side and they, too, were very good. Similar to the bread, a crunchy outer layer and a soft, potato-y core.
I really wanted to linger for a good part of the rest of the afternoon at District Tap House, but I needed to get back to the hotel to do some office stuff on my computer. Rayleen was a fun and accommodating server during my time at District Tap House. The ambiance of the place was warm, cozy and comfortable, the kind of place where one would want to linger after dinner or lunch for another drink or two. I've hit a few pubs during my trips to New York, but I have to think that District Tap House is No. 1 on my list, so far.