I was staying on the north side of Indianapolis on a recent trip out there and I was looking for places to eat in the area. Sometimes, I'll find a place on a map or GPS and when I pull up in front of it, I realize that I've already eaten there. That happened to me this time, as well. I was sort of resigned to go back and eat there until I looked across the parking lot at another place called Drake's that looked like it was interesting.
Bruce Drake was a restaurateur in Lexington, KY running a seafood restaurant - Drake's Regatta. One of his regular customers was Brian McCarty who had an opportunity to buy a restaurant. McCarty called upon Drake for advice, both in purchasing the restaurant and then running the place. In 1997, McCarty bought A.P. Suggins restaurant in Lexington.
Two men who were regular customers at McCarty's restaurant were also developers of the Landsdowne Shoppes upscale shopping and entertainment area in Lexington. An upscale steakhouse in the immediate area had moved to a new location and the developers asked McCarty if he would be interested in putting a similar restaurant in the development. Once again, McCarty called upon Drake - only this time it would be more than just advice. He asked Drake to become a partner in the new restaurant.
McCarty and Drake worked on a concept and traveled to other markets to try restaurants for ideas. It was at a restaurant in Atlanta where the owner there told the two that they needed to go to Chicago to try a couple of the "prime beef" restaurants there. Following a couple meals at the Chicago steak houses, Drake and McCarty came up with the concept for Malone's, the first prime beef restaurant in Lexington. They opened Malone's nearly 20 years ago and it continues to be the top destination for prime beef steaks in Lexington.
Using Malone's as a cornerstone, McCarty and Drake set up a restaurant group called Bluegrass Hospitality Group. Early on, the corporation was a Damon's Ribs franchisee, but they also developed restaurants in and around Lexington such as Sal's Chophouse, Meats BBQ, Harry's, Aqua Sushi and OBC Kitchen.
One of the first restaurants that McCarty and Drake came up with was an upscale casual eatery/piano bar by the name of Oscar's. Oscar's opened in 2000 in Lexington and was open for nearly 9 years until the piano bar craze sort of ended. Bluegrass Entertainment rebranded Oscar's as Drake's - a casual eatery/sushi bar (Aqua Sushi), and a dance hall with the tag line "Come Play". The concept went over so well that they soon opened two more Drake's in Louisville and one in Huntsville, AL. The Indianapolis Drake's was opened in 2012 by a franchisee, and there's also company-owned and franchisee locations in Florence, KY, Franklin, TN, and Knoxville, TN, with two more locations opening (if they haven't opened already) in a suburb of Lexington, and one in Bristol, TN.
The Drake's in Indianapolis is located near the Keystone Crossing area along E. 82nd St. (see map) I got into Drake's around 8 p.m. on an unseasonably warm early spring evening. Record high temperatures had been broken in Indianapolis that day and the staff had opened the large patio windows that looked out from the bar. Because of that, the bar area was pretty full, but I was able to find a spot at the bar.
The back part of Drake's featured what appeared to be a shamrock shaped bar, and had a number of tables throughout the area. This was also the area where their Aqua Sushi sushi bar was located. I had a hard time reconciling the fact that a sports bar had a sushi place located in it. But, there seemed to be some people having sushi in this area.
After I was seated, I was greeted by Krystal, one of the bartender/servers that evening. She offered up a food menu and asked me what I'd like to drink. They had 20-some beers on tap and I noticed that they had the Three Floyd's Alpha King pale ale on tap. I like to drink the Alpha King and when I have it I think of my buddy Craig who died of cancer unexpectedly five or six years ago. He was the one who turned me on to Alpha King a number of years ago.
For supposedly being an upscale sports bar, the menu didn't really reflect that. It featured foods that were your standard sports pub fare - burgers, sandwiches, appetizers, salads, and a few entrees such as seared salmon, tacos with beer-battered fish, pan-seared chicken breasts, and a Korean BBQ chicken flatbread. I also could have ordered sushi at the bar, if I wanted.
I almost ordered the chicken tenders, but I ended up getting the Mushroom/Swiss cheese burger instead. I asked Krystal if they could put bacon on the burger, as well. I got a choice of a side with the burger and there wasn't much to choose from - seasoned fries, broccoli florets, waffled sweet potato fries, and cole slaw - but they did have tater tots! I was set.
The burger was presented to me in a metal pan on a bed of wax paper. The burger patty was sitting on chopped lettuce, shredded red onion, and a slice of tomato. I could tell pretty easily that the bun was dry, but I decided I'd be able to get around that.
Well, it turned out that it was a good thing the bun was dry because the burger was juicy and messy from the first bite. The bun did a good job of staying together and sopping up the juiciness from the burger and the messiness from the Swiss cheese and mushrooms. It was definitely a multi-napkin burger. It turned out to be a lot better than I initially thought it would be.
The tater tots were a great side with the meal. The only problem is that they couldn't find any hot sauce for me to use on the tater tots until someone came from the kitchen with a bottle of Tabasco where they had purposely pulled out the drip hole at the top of the bottle. I had to gingerly pour some of the Tabasco sauce out onto the wax paper making sure that I didn't pour the whole damned bottle out onto my plate.
Drake's might not have been my first choice that evening, but it turned out to be pretty good one. The Swiss/mushroom/bacon burger I had was juicy and messy, the tater tots were a nice compliment to the burger, and they had a good beer selection including the Three Floyd's Alpha King of which I enjoyed a couple of those. While the place was busy - the bartenders were hopping the whole time I was there - they were still able to keep up with any needs that I had. The only thing that I can't reconcile is having a sushi bar in a sports pub. But other than sushi, it's pretty much your standard sports grub. If you're looking for something like that on the north side of Indy, Drake's is a good place to try.