I was staying out near O'Hare during a trip into Chicago and I wanted to find someplace to eat in nearby Park Ridge. I was initially going to have dinner at Harp & Fiddle, an Irish restaurant that I had visited a handful of times before that specializes in comfort foods. (Click here to see the entry on Harp & Fiddle). However, after parking the car and walking toward the Irish pub, a place next to it caught my eye - an American-style, farm-to-fork restaurant by the name of Pennyville Station. It piqued my interest enough that I decided to have dinner there that night.
Tino Antonacci was a serial restaurateur and owned the popular Basta Pasta Italian restaurant with locations in Chicago's far northwest Edison Park neighborhood and out in west suburban Oakbrook Terrace. Antonacci's son Tony was literally brought up in the restaurant business learning how to cook in the kitchen and eventually becoming the general manager of the Edison Park location in his early 20's. One day, a young lady by the name of Samantha came in to apply for a job. She was going to school at DePaul University and wanted to make some money as a waitress. Samantha was hired and it wasn't long until she and Tony Antonacci became a couple. The two eventually married and settled in Chicago.
About 8 years ago, Tino Antonacci retired and closed the Basta Pasta restaurants. Wanting to get out of Chicago, Tony and Samantha Antonacci set their sights on Park Ridge as a place to raise their three young girls. But Tony Antonnaci had been wanting to run his own restaurant for years and he saw a potential restaurant in the making when a spot opened up on Main Street. With the help of his father, Tony Antonacci opened Pennyville Station in June of 2019. The original name of Park Ridge was Pennyville and the restaurant was located across from the Metra train station in Park Ridge.
Walking into Pennyville Station the bar area is immediately up front and to the right. The striking and ornate backbar features a Pennyville Station sign that is made out from thousands of pennies that Tony Antonacci received from various Park Ridge residents. The wooden shelves holding liquor were flanked by two flatscreen televisions and small model train cars were across the top of the structure.
The kitchen was just past the bar and featured another small metal-topped bar area where people could sit and watch the chefs at work. However, I didn't see anyone sit there while I was in the restaurant. The open kitchen featured a large Kamado Joe ceramic grill - something you don't normally see in a kitchen.
Pennyville Station is a long and narrow space that features banquette seating along the long wall with booths in the back. Elegant chandeliers and ornate light fixtures hung from the ceiling giving the brick-walled dining space an old time, yet classy sort of feel. Historical pictures of Pennyville hung from the brick wall above the padded banquette benches.
In the winter of 2022/23, Pennyville Station redid the space next door that was called The Bar Car. It was originally designed to be a live music and events area with space for restaurant overflow. But Antonacci renovated the spot with stylish chandeliers hanging above and incorporated it into the restaurant adding up to 80 more seats. Just from the decor alone, I really liked what I saw at Pennyville Station and felt very comfortable in the place.
At first, a hostess tried to seat me at one of the tables with the banquette seating along the wall in the main dining room, but if you're a regular reader of Road Tips you know how much I detest banquette seating. As I turned back toward the front bar, a couple was getting up from their seats to leave. I asked her if I could take one of the seats at the bar. "Sure," the young hostess said cheerfully. I plopped down in the recently vacated bar stool and was handed a food menu.
A young man by the name of Jacob was one of the bartenders that evening. He greeted me and asked what I wanted to drink. I didn't really know what they had and he said, "Oh, wait. Let me get you a drink menu." The drink menu featured wines, specialty cocktails and a small beer list in the bottom corner. The beer list had a number of domestic beers, a few imported beers, and a handful of craft beers. I saw that they had the Maplewood Brewery and Distillery Son of Juice hazy IPA and I ordered up one of those.
The menu at Pennyville Station wasn't deep, but they had a number of interesting items to choose from. The appetizers featured fried calamari with sliced cherry peppers, a spinach and artichoke dip with tortilla chips, and a lemon & basil hummus with pita bread that I knew my wife would have probably enjoyed if she were with me.
Pennyville Station has a prime rib special Wednesday thru Sunday evenings. But I was there on a Tuesday night and it wasn't available. The linguine with shrimp entree sounded good, but I had pasta the previous evening. The pan-seared scallops sounded delectable, as did the bone-in Duroc pork chop served with feta cheese mashed potatoes. There was a lobster roll, a Wagyu burger with cheddar cheese, and a panko-crusted fried chicken breast sandwich on the menu.
In the end - and because I was thinking of some comfort food before I walked into Pennyville Station - I ordered the stout-braised short rib entree. It was served over a mixture of barley, carrots and celery and then topped with a stout and beef stock reduction.
From the first bite, I knew I had made the right choice. The beef short rib was tender and easy to cut. The stout and beef stock gravy gave it a hearty flavor with each bite. The barley, carrots and celery were a nice complement to the braised short rib. This was an excellent meal.
A guy had taken the seat next to me not long after I ordered my food. When someone from the kitchen brought it out and set it down in front of me, I could tell the guy was eyeing what I got. After a couple bites, I may have said, "Mmmmmm..." loud enough for him to hear me.
He asked, "What IS that?" I told him it was the braised short rib and that it was outstanding. He put down his menu and said, "You sold me." And he ordered the same thing from Jacob.
I enjoyed every aspect of my visit to Pennyville Station. From the grand and exquisite - yet not pretentious - decor, to the great service I received from Jacob, to the exceptional meal that I had, everything about Pennyville Station was top-notch. The stout-braised beef short rib was phenomenal and a complete spot-hitter for me. Park Ridge has a lot of good restaurants to choose from, but I think that Pennyville Station may have moved to the top of my list.