Out in Fort Wayne for a day-long seminar with our biggest account, we had invited a recording studio mastering engineer from Nashville to help out with the presentation. After finishing the seminar, packing up and getting everything ready to ship back to our warehouse, I said it was time for a beer and some food. Both my colleague from Montreal and our friend from Nashville were up for that. Since my colleague is a vegetarian, he's always up for pasta and I remembered a place that we had passed a couple nights previously that I wanted to try out. That evening we went to Casa! Ristorante.
Tom Casaburo grew up in Highland, NY, located just across the Hudson River from Poughkeepsie, about halfway between New York City and Albany. After high school, Casaburo joined the Marines and had a 3-year stint in the armed forces. After getting out of the Marines, Casaburo enrolled at Saint Peters College (now Saint Peters University) in Jersey City, NJ on the GI Bill and got his English degree. Soon after he got out of college, Casaburo joined the FBI and was sent to Fort Wayne in 1968. In 1972, Casaburo was hired as Fort Wayne's first Director of Public Safety, a post he held until 1976.
It was a chance meeting at a local bar with St. Louis-native Jimmy D'Angelo where Casaburo started to get an idea about opening an Italian restaurant in Fort Wayne. It turned out that D'Angelo's cousins Vince and Joe Cunetto ran an Italian restaurant in St. Louis - Cunetto House of Pasta - using recipes handed down by their maternal grandmother who was also Jimmy D'Angelo's grandmother.
After Casaburo resigned as the public safety director, Casaburo and Jimmy D (as he was known) went to St. Louis to learn the recipes from D'Angelo's cousins. After immersing themselves in the kitchen and learning the made-from-scratch recipes from Grandma D'Angelo, the two went back to Fort Wayne to open their restaurant. Casa Ristorante Italiano opened on Coldwater Road in 1977 and it was an immediate hit with the local populace.
Pictured right - Tom Casaburo, Sr. Photo courtesy Fort Wayne Journal Gazette.
A second Casa location opened on Fairfield Road in 1980. It was considered the flagship location for the Casa Restaurant Group in the early 80's. The original Coldwater Road location closed and moved to a new spot on Parnell Ave. in the late 80's just across from Memorial Coliseum. The Fairfield Road location closed in the early 90's, but was replaced by the restaurant on W. Jefferson in 1993.
In 1993, Jimmy D decided to retire and Casaburo bought his shares. Casaburo's sons - Tom, Jr. (known as T) and Jim started working at the restaurants as pre-teens, both busing tables and helping with kitchen prep. In 1996, the Casaburo family opened their third restaurant on Fort Wayne's north side in 1996, and a fourth location opened on the northeast side of the city in 2002. When Tom Casaburo, Sr. and his wife, Sharon, decided to retire to Florida, the two sons took over the business with Jim designated as the managing partner.
It was the W. Jefferson location that we went to that evening. Located on the main road into the heart of Fort Wayne from the southwest side of the city, it was about a five minute drive from our hotel. (see map). Going into the restaurant, we were greeted by someone at the host counter near the front door. The man asked if we wanted to sit in the lounge. It was a pretty big lounge with a three-sided bar. Had I been dining by myself, I would have probably sat at the bar. But the lounge was pretty busy and we decided to take a table in the dining room.
On the way back to the dining room, we passed a large brick oven they've used since the early 90's to make their wood-fired pizzas. The tile work and cowling on the brick oven was similar to the front of the fireplace in the lounge.
We were led back to a table in the dining room. The dining area was brightly lit with colorful paintings of old Italy on the walls. A large flower decoration was the centerpiece of the room.
After we were seated, we were given menus to look through. And after a bit our server for the evening - Adreyn - came by to greet us. He asked if we had been to Casa! before and we told him that we were from out of town. He asked where and I pointed at my colleague and said, "Montreal." Then pointed at our friend and said, "Nashville." And then I said, "And I'm from Iowa."
Adreyn perked up. "Where in Iowa?" I told him that I was from Davenport. He said, "I grew up in Clear Lake!" When I told him that I grew up in Newton, he was even more surprised. Adreyn turned out to be a great guy and was really attentive and helpful during our visit.
It was a pretty full menu in terms of pasta, sandwiches, appetizers, salads, and entrees such as rotisserie grilled pork chops, a grilled salmon filet, chicken parm, and filet tips kabobs. But in terms of beer and wine offerings, it was a pretty short list. There wasn't a lot of craft beers on the menu, but they did have Peroni on tap. Each of us signed up for one each. Later in the evening, I got a glass of the Catena Malbec they had available.
None of us had eaten lunch, so we were pretty hungry. I let my colleague and our friend pick what they wanted to start out with for appetizers. My colleague got the bruschetta - it turned out to be a "construct-your-own" style of bruschetta. A plate of toasted baguette slices was brought to the table with a cup of chopped tomatoes and basil leaves mixed with olive oil. I thought it was a bit strange, but went along with it. I thought the bread with the tomatoes and basil were very good, but my colleague - who I've found during our time together is a bit of a bread snob - didn't care for the bread. (He makes his own bread at home.)
But after having what our friend ordered, I didn't worry about the bruschetta. He ordered the garlic knots - bread dough tied into small knots, then deep-fried and served in a bowl of garlic butter topped with Parmesan cheese and chopped parsley. These were outstanding and very decadent in terms of being a healthy choice. I had 3 of the garlic knots and completely forgot about the bruschetta to my left.
They had a lot of choices for pasta dishes including baked pasta dishes such as eggplant Parmagiano, lasagna, and large pasta shells stuffed with a combination of three different types of cheese. Regular pasta dishes included a fettuccine alfredo, meat-filled tortellini in an herb-butter sauce, penne pasta with sausage and pepperoni slices, and a seafood linguine. One of the specials that evening was a spinach fettuccine in a cream sauce. I could add chicken or shrimp to the dish. I seriously considered that.
Our friend went with the penne bianco - it featured Italian sausage, mushrooms and spinach mixed with penne pasta in a Parmesan cream cheese sauce, then topped with provolone and mozzarella cheeses and baked. When Adreyn put the dish in front of our friend, he exclaimed, "Oh, man! That's a lot of food! How am I going to finish all this?"
He certainly made a dent in the dish, though. He said it was extremely rich with the creamy Parmesan sauce and the provolone and mozzarella cheese on top of the penne pasta mixture. But he also said that it was very delicious. When he threw in the towel, Adreyn asked if he wanted a to-go box. Our friend said that he didn't think it would travel very well back to Nashville.
My colleague was happy to see that Casa! Ristorante had a significant vegetarian part of the menu including spinach lasagna, cheese-stuffed ravioli, pasta and marinara sauce, and cavatelli pasta with mushrooms and a choice of another vegetable. He thought about getting the pasta primavera, but he ended up ordering the risotto Alberto, sans the grilled chicken breast that came with the dish. It featured wild mushrooms, zucchini, yellow onions and asparagus simmered in a rich stock, then mixed with arborio rice in a creamy white wine sauce and Parmesan cheese. He thought it was good - not great - but he was happy that he got it.
I was in somewhat of a quandary. I really thought about the spinach fettuccine special they had that night. The fettuccine carbonara was also interesting to me, as was the meat-stuffed ravioli. And the meat-filled tortellini was another thing that I was thinking hard about.
When Adreyn came to me to give him my order, I was stuck. "All good choices," he said after I told him what I was looking at. "Let me suggest something that's one of our more popular dishes." He then told me about the Lasagna Carne Amante. "It's sort of like a 'meat-lovers' lasagna," he told me. It was a large block of their lasagna only with Italian sausage, pepperoni, prosciutto and sliced meatballs. It's topped with their house meat sauce and a cheese blend before it's baked in the oven. I thought, "OK - that sounds like a challenge!"
The meat-overload lasagna was just that - thick chunks of Italian sausage and sliced meatballs, spicy pepperoni slices, and thin-sliced imported prosciutto mixed in with lasagna noodles, a thick layer of cheese and a thick and hearty meat sauce. It was just a lot of food. I was able to finish just over half of the chunk of lasagna in the dish before I declared I was done. Adreyn also asked me if I wanted to take what was left with me. Had I lived locally, I probably would have. But A) I wasn't certain a to-go box would fit in my hotel refrigerator; and B) I had a 5 hour drive back to Iowa the next day and I didn't have anything that I could keep it cool in.
My colleague from Montreal was sort of neutral about Casa! Ristorante. We had gone to another Italian restaurant in Fort Wayne - Salvatori's - last year and he seemed to favor that place over the other ones we had been to on subsequent visits to Fort Wayne. But I thought what I had at Casa! Ristorante was very good, and our friend from Memphis thought what he was also way above par. I can't say enough about our service from Adreyn that evening - friendly, efficient, just a great guy all around. While my colleague might not want to go back to Casa! Ristorante any time soon, I'd have no problem heading back there on a future visit to Fort Wayne.