While up in Milwaukee last summer, my wife wanted to go somewhere for breakfast. We had thought about going to Johnny V's, a classic diner that my wife and I were turned on to by a cousin of mine who used to live in Milwaukee years ago, but the last couple times I had been there I felt the quality of the food - and service - had slipped. Then we found out that Johnny V's had closed down during the pandemic in 2020. I remembered a breakfast place that one of my former accounts had turned me onto a number of years ago - John's Sandwich Shop on North Ave. in Wauwatosa. We drove up to Wauwatosa - known simply as 'Tosa' to the locals - and went to John's for breakfast. However, when I pulled up to the place, I found that it was no longer John's Sandwich Shop but another restaurant by the name of MidTown Grill. It turns out that John's had closed in 2017 after being in business 54 years. I looked at my wife and shrugged my shoulders. "We're here," I said. "We may as well give it a try."
Mike Topolovich grew up just a couple blocks from where the MidTown Grill is today. In fact, as a teenager he used to take his skateboard and ride it around the parking lot on the west side of what was then John's Sandwich Shop. Owner Peter Hyndiuk had purchased John's in 1991 from John Canter who started the restaurant in 1963. Hyndiuk was getting annoyed by the teenager coming to the parking lot day after day just to ride his skateboard. One day, Hyndiuk offered Topolovich a job and the 15-year-old turned him down. He ended up going to work at a McDonald's instead.
When the job at McDonald's fell through, Topolovich went back to Hyndiuk and asked him if the job was still available. It turned out that it was and Topolovich started out working in the kitchen prepping food and bussing tables. However, unlike other teenagers who work at jobs and then quit when they get out of high school, Topolovich stayed on at John's and worked there until he was in his late 20's learning the ropes of running a restaurant.
Pictured right - Mike Topolovich. Photo courtesy Milwaukee Journal Sentinel.
An opportunity to be a chef at a more elegant restaurant came up for Topolovich and he quit John's and went on to bigger and better things. But after a couple years, the lure of the home nest came up for Topolovich as Hyndiuk offered him a chance to come back and basically run John's Sandwich Shop. Topolovich jumped at the chance went back to John's in 2012.
A year later, a new restaurant similar to John's Sandwich Shop opened up about a mile east of John's. The North Ave. Grill featured American diner-style foods with an emphasis on breakfasts and lunches. But the owners of the restaurant were having problems and decided to sell less than 8 months after they opened the doors.
Topolovich heard that the place was up for sale and along with his father Peter, Mike Topolovich bought the North Ave. Grill in late 2013. After resetting the place and changing a few things around, North Ave. Grill reopened in early 2014.
After leaving John's Sandwich Shop, it was evident that Peter Hyndiuk was having problems without Topolovich on board. Without any warning, the restaurant closed in December of 2017. The small restaurant was closed for just a few days when the Topolovich's decided to buy the place where Mike got his start in the restaurant business. He took over ownership of the restaurant on January 1, 2018.
There needed to be some changes and renovations at the former John's Sandwich Shop and it took some time to get the place cleaned and set back up as a new restaurant. Topolovich didn't want it to be called John's Sandwich Shop and initially settled on a place simply called "The Grill". But by the time he finished sprucing up the place, getting all his permits in order and was ready to open in September of 2018, he changed the name to MidTown Grill.
Of course, I didn't know any of that story when we pulled up to the former John's Sandwich Shop that morning. We were able to park in the lot on the west side of the building where Topolovich used to ride his skateboard as a teenager. (See map) The small patio dining area in front of the building was filled on that beautiful Wisconsin morning and we went inside to find a place to sit.
Now, I had been in John's Sandwich Shop two or three times since I first went there nearly 13 years ago. It was definitely dated and cramped, so it was somewhat of a pleasant surprise to see the renovations Topolovich did with the place. Although it's the same sized space, Topolovich redesigned the restaurant to make it seem more open. The open kitchen area is still there, but everything was stainless steel from the vent hood to the order pick-up area. LED light fixtures on decorative beams over the dining area gave the place a vibrant feel. Whereas John's Sandwich Shop had more warm colors on the walls, MidTown Grill had brighter shades giving it a more modern appeal.
We had a young lady take us to a table along the wall and drop off menus for us to look through. It turned out she was also our server that morning, Pam. My wife got a coffee and I got an orange juice to start out.
Many of the same breakfast items that John's had to offer were on the menu at MidTown Grill. Topolovich also migrated some of the items found on the menu at North Ave. Grill over to the MidTown Grill such as the strawberry cheesecake waffle and the berry-berry waffle, avocado toast, and the fish fry which is served only on Friday's after 4 p.m. For the lunch crowd, burgers, wraps, salads and fried chicken are available. For breakfast, MidTown Grill offers breakfast quesadillas, power bowls, skillets, chicken and waffles, and omelets.
The power bowls MidTown Grill offered intrigued my wife and she ended up getting the MidTown power bowl - a blend of chopped vegetables with roasted tomatoes, artichoke hearts and a five-grain blend that included white and red quinoa and white rice. 2 eggs were included with the power bowl and my wife got scrambled eggs. It was a big bowl of food and my wife made a serious dent in it before she was finally through. She thought the MidTown power bowl was delicious.
I wasn't quite as hungry as my wife that morning, but I knew that it may be awhile before we would be eating again since we were traveling that day. I got the "build-your-own" omelet with sausage, mushroom and pepper jack cheese. A side of hash browns and toast came on the side. The omelet was good - even better when I spiced it up with some Cholula hot sauce. It was a basic omelet and it was fine for what it was.
As much as I liked John's Sandwich Shop, I have to say that I like MidTown Grill a little better - mainly because John's decor had gotten tired and the menu seemed to be more updated for 21st century tastes. Our service from Pam was very good - she brought my wife the wrong power bowl and had to run back to grab the correct one off the serving bar. But she was efficient and friendly. For not realizing John's had closed and was replaced by a new restaurant that I certainly wasn't familiar with, our experience at MidTown Grill turned out to be positive all around.