During our stay in Murrells Inlet, South Carolina just outside of Myrtle Beach, we had a number of choices of restaurants to pick from in the area. Known for their seafood restaurants, we were looking for a place for lunch where I could get a burger and my wife could get a salad with some protein on it. Now, some of the places in the area, I just didn't care for their names - no matter how popular or good they may have been. I wasn't going to eat at the Dead Dog Saloon, Creek Ratz, or Drunken Jack's. The names alone just seemed to be too touristy for my taste - even if they really weren't tourist joints. But there was one place that we had passed a number of times that both from the name and from the outside of the building I thought would be a bit more upscale than some of the other places with the funky names. We pulled into J Peters Grill & Bar on the MarshWalk to have lunch one afternoon.
Jon Peter Angell was a native New Yorker who made the move to South Carolina a number of years ago to help out his brother, Dan, who was helping to open restaurants in Charleston and Myrtle Beach. Jon's brother first employed his younger brother as a dishwasher before he rose through the ranks of various restaurants and bars his brother was managing. After a few years, Jon decided to get completely out of the bar business and found other lines of work in the meantime.
In the meantime, Dan Angell had met another lifetime restauranteur, Jason McDowell, during his rounds of working at restaurants in Columbia, SC. McDowell was working on a concept for a casual upscale restaurant, something Jon Angell had been thinking about, as well. Dan Angell put the two together and in January of 2010 they had opened their first restaurant - J Peters - in Anderson, SC on the western side of the state.
From there, the partners - along with Dan Angell - opened a number of J Peters locations across the state and into Georgia and North Carolina. At one point, there were 14 J Peters locations run by the Angells and McDowell with two locations of another concept - The Rusty Anchor restaurant and Catfish Johnny's bar.
In 2019, McDowell approached Jon Angell about a proposition to buy him out of their partnership while maintaining ownership of some of the J Peters locations. Angell and McDowell had an amicable separation allowing McDowell to rebrand four of the J Peters restaurants in the greater Columbia area to J.R. Cash's Grill & Bar (the initials of his two oldest children with the "Cash" coming from his youngest child's name).
That same year, Angell and his brother opened their second Myrtle Beach-area location on the MarshWalk along Business Route US 17 in Murrells Inlet. (see map) That was the location that we went to for lunch after spending a large portion of the morning at Brookgreen Gardens just south of Murrells Inlet.
They have a very nice patio at J Peters. We had the option of sitting on the patio, but we had just spent over 3 hours out in the South Carolina coastal heat and humidity, so we decided to sit inside.
The view from the patio looking out over the MarshWalk and the marsh beyond that was actually quite nice. Palmetto trees bordered the walk way and the water left over from the tide that had gone out earlier was a deep azure in color. It would have been relaxing to sit on the deck, but it was also pretty hot.
The main dining room at J Peters featured a number of large booths. This is where we sat during our visit to J Peters. Our server that day was a lady by the name of Bethany. We chatted with her during part of our time there and found that she was originally from Cromwell, CT. "Lower taxes, lower prices, better place to raise my kids," she told us as to how she found her way to South Carolina. "It's a great place to live."
The bar at J Peters was off to the side of the dining room. It wasn't all that large and could seat about 15 or 16 people. Brush aluminum plating was the edging around the bar with accent lighting on the back bar. It was a full service bar and my wife was able to get her Tito's and cranberry juice with a lime, while I went with an Air Bruch hazy IPA from the Grand Strand Brewing Company up the road in Myrtle Beach.
J Peters had an upstairs area for overflow dining or for groups. The upstairs dining room looked out over a glass partition down into the main dining room on one side and out over the patio and marsh on the other.
Looking over the menu, J Peters featured a wide variety of sandwiches, appetizers, soups, salads, aged Midwestern steaks, and entrees such as blackened chicken alfredo, fresh Atlantic salmon, and hand-breaded deep-fried flounder filets. Prime rib was available every day at J Peters as was a prime rib sandwich.
My wife wanted to try J Peters version of the she-crab soup, something that we saw on a lot of menus in restaurants during our time in South Carolina. Originally made in the early 1900's in Charleston, she-crab soup is called that as the crab roe from female crabs was one of the main ingredients in the soup. Lump crabmeat is the main ingredient in most of the she-crab soups we saw during our time there. The J Peters version was a very creamy and buttery bisque with generous chunks of crabmeat in the soup. It was simply wonderful in flavor.
For her lunch selection, my wife ended up with the blackened steak Caesar salad. It featured chunks of blackened sirloin steak on romaine lettuce with shaved parmesan cheese. A hearty Caesar dressing came on the side. Her steak salad also came with J Peters' signature freshly baked honey-butter croissant. They're so popular they're included in the appetizer section of the menu. My wife was very happy with her selections for lunch.
I thought about getting the prime rib sandwich, but in the end I went with the house burger. It was a 10 ounce blended ground beef patty with the full complement of dill pickles, red onions, sliced tomatoes and lettuce on a toasted bun. I had my choice of cheese to go on the burger and I went with Monterey jack. The burger was delicious - juicy and full of flavor. It was a multiple napkin burger as the tomatoes were very fresh and the burger was oozing the cooked-in marbling from the beef. The bun held together very well with all that messiness. Fries came on the side and they were also very good. They had that great crispy outside shell with an almost creamy potato inner core. This was an excellent lunch all the way around.
J Peters is the perfect antidote to the "catchy" named tourist destination restaurants that you find on the MarshWalk in Murrells Inlet. It was a stylish place without any pretension or snobbish-nature. The food we had was very good, as was the service from Bethany. If you're looking for a little more of an upscale atmosphere from the bars and grills on the MarshWalk, J Peters fits the bill.