One of the evenings while we were in Santa Fe, we decided to try out a place that had come highly recommended by the staff over at (the since closed) Fire & Hops restaurant. When talking with a couple people over there as to where we should go for a good dinner, they both told us, "You need to go to Horno." One of them turned another person nearby and said, "Hey, where else should the try for dinner while they're here in Santa Fe?" He immediately said, "Horno." So we made reservations to give Horno a try.
David Sellers was living in New Hampshire and working toward a degree in philosophy. While going to college, he was working as a baker at an all-organic bakery where he learned about locally-sourced sustainable foods made from scratch. After graduating from Plymouth State University, Sellers made his way out to San Francisco where he learned more about cooking at restaurants in the bay area. By 1997, the call of the southwest was strong for Sellers and he ended up in Santa Fe where he was the sous chef for Santacafé, an elegant restaurant situated in an early 20th century house.
It was at Santacafé where Sellers met a young lady by the name of Heather. Heather had grown up in upstate New York and had worked in restaurants in the Ithaca area before moving to New York City to pursue a modeling/actress career. To help pay the bills between gigs, Heather worked for various fine dining restaurants under the Cafe Concepts umbrella, then later with the Fireman Hospitality Group where she helped open the acclaimed Redeye Grill located just across the street from Carnegie Hall. It turned out that she was much more proficient working as a front of house restaurant manager than she was as an actress.
But Heather was looking for something more in life and in 1998 she moved to New Mexico to join the AmeriCorps VISTA volunteer program that was associated with the Boys and Girls Club of Santa Fe. And to make some additional money on the side, Heather went to work at Santacafé where she worked as a server, then was later the front of house manager. That's where she met David Sellers.
Pictured right - Heather and David Sellers. Photo courtesy Edible New Mexico.
David and Heather became a couple and married soon after. After 10 years at Santacafé, the couple opened their first restaurant together in Santa Fe by the name of Amavi, a critically-acclaimed bistro that specialized in Mediterranean cuisine and wine selections.
After running Amavi for 4 years, the Sellers sold Amavi and moved to Connecticut where he was the head chef at Max Fish, a New England-style farm-to-table seafood restaurant and raw bar in Glastonbury. But, once again, the call of the southwest beckoned David and Heather, and in 2014 the couple and their two boys moved to Albuquerque to help establish the Street Food Institute - a non-profit organization designed to help budding culinary entrepreneurs who wanted to get into the burgeoning food-truck community in the city.
While David worked with young people teaching the basics from food prep to business plans, Heather was working toward her master's degree in social work through New Mexico Highlands University. After getting her master's, Heather joined Communities in Schools a non-profit organization which worked with at-risk students to help keep them in school and engaged.
But the restaurant life was pulling at the Sellers. And like a number of restaurants during and directly after the pandemic, an Italian restaurant in Santa Fe closed their doors. David and Heather had been working on a new concept for a restaurant where they could have high quality sustainably-grown/locally-sourced foods that weren't going to be tough on the diner's wallet and would be inviting for all walks of life. When the space that housed the former Il Piatto Italian restaurants in Santa Fe became available, the Sellers jumped at the chance to move back to New Mexico's capital city and open their conceptual dream restaurant - Horno.
In Spanish, "horno" means oven. Most ovens in Mexican and Southwestern cultures of days gone by were situated outside the home, usually in a courtyard where families would meet and have communal meals. The Sellers wanted Horno to have that same family and community vibe where their motto - "Food for the People" - would be fitting for their restaurant.
We made reservations for 7:30 that evening and we found the adobe-style structure along Marcy Street in downtown Santa Fe. (see map) We were lucky in that a car was pulling out just a few spots down the street from Horno. We were a few minutes early when we walked up to the hostess stand. She said our table was ready (a nice change from restaurants who want you to spend time at the bar while they "prep" your table between seatings) and she took us into the small of the two dining rooms at Horno. This dining space had a small bar with about 10 4-seat tables in the room.
Our server that evening was a guy by the name of Edward. Edward turned out to be a wealth of information on everything New Mexico. (More on that later on.) He gave us the specials going on that evening and then asked for our drink order. I ordered an Ex Novo IPA from Corrales, NM, a suburb of Albuquerque. My wife got the fresh-squeezed red grapefruit paloma. She likes palomas, but the red grapefruit they used in this one was a little too strong of a taste for her. Nonetheless, she ended up drinking it down.
Looking through the seasonal menu from Horno, there were a handful of farm-to-fork organically-raised Southeast Asian and Italian cuisine-inspired items to choose from. From time-to-time David Sellers also features his award-winning green chile cheeseburger on the menu, a two-time winner of the best green chile burger in the state of New Mexico.
Horno also has a pretty extensive wine list, all of which is curated by David Sellers. We were both leaning toward seafood items from the menu, so I ordered up a bottle of the 2021 Feudi di San Gregorio Falanghina from Italy. It was an easy-drinking white wine that had a full-bodied texture. It went extremely well with what we ordered that evening.
My wife started out with the roasted gold beet salad. It came with fresh greens, sliced avocados, and was topped with a pumpkin seed piñon granola and a dill vinaigrette dressing. She said the taste of her salad was "amazing". She offered me a bite of her salad, but I was too busy concentrating on my appetizer.
I got the tuna tartare on a risotto cake. The tuna tartare was mixed with sturia caviar, chive butter and arugula, and finished off with a lemon/lime reduction. This was simply unbelievable. The risotto cake was deep fried with a crunchy outer shell that came apart very easily with my fork. It was one of the more incredible things I've ever eaten.
I could have really stopped with just the tuna tartare with the risotto cake, it was so scrumptious and rich that I didn't know if anything else I would have had that evening would have been able to top that dish. But I found something pretty close in the seafood with squid ink capellini pasta. This was a heavenly meal in itself. It featured chunks of seafood mixed with chopped crab meat with dark green - nearly black - squid ink-infused capellini noodles. It was topped with a butter cream sauce that was to absolutely die for. In fact, they had slices of focaccia brought with the meals and after I cleared my plate of the pasta and seafood, I used a couple of the focaccia slices to sponge up the sauce. It was outrageously great all around.
My wife got the seafood special that evening - pink grouper fresh-caught off the coast of Baja California. It came with a roasted corn succotash with roasted herbed tomatoes. The pink grouper sat on a risotto cake similar to the one I had with the tuna tartare. There was also a beurre blanc (white cream butter) sauce on the base of the plate.
From the first bite, my wife was in epicurean heaven. "This is one of the best things I've ever had in my life," she said after three or four bites. Thankfully she offered me a bit as I gave her a bite of my seafood pasta. Once again, she had picked the better of the two meals. And that's not to say that my seafood pasta was bad - far from it. But the pink grouper with the roasted succotash and tomatoes on a risotto cake with the beurre blanc sauce was absolutely heavenly.
My wife was worried that she wouldn't be able to eat the whole meal because it was very rich, but she surprised herself by pretty much finishing everything on her plate. She even sopped up some of the beurre blanc sauce with the focaccia bread we had on the table. After she threw in the towel, she sat back in her seat, took a drink from her wine glass and started to chuckle. "That meal was something else," she said with a bit of a laugh.
I didn't expect that we'd want any dessert, but Edward brought out the dessert menu for us to look over. And all it took was a quick glance at one of the items - the blueberry "pop-tart" topped with vanilla ice cream with a blueberry compote and finished with powdered sugar. This, too, was spectacular on its own. Even though we were both full, the blueberry "pop-tart" with the vanilla ice cream was just too good to pass up.
As we were savoring our dinner over a final glass of wine, Edward came over to check on us. Most of the other patrons had finished their meals and moved on in the night, so my wife engaged Edward in conversation. We found out that Edward first came to New Mexico in his teens on a boy scout retreat. "I wanted to get back here in the worst way," he told us. "So, I came back to go to college in Albuquerque."
Edward told us that he was a history major with an emphasis on New Mexican history. For 21 years, he was a fly fishing guide who moonlighted as a tour guide for area historical sites. He's worked off and on as a waiter during the winter months which started during his years at the University of New Mexico and, as he put it, "I'm blessed to be married to a woman who has a good job with the state of New Mexico." He said that most people who live in Santa Fe are working for three different entities - the state, tourism and hospitality (hotels, restaurants), or film production as the are a number of film and video studios in the immediate area around Santa Fe.
As I said, Edward turned out to be a wealth of information about places to visit, things to see, and roads to take in and around Sante Fe, Chimayo, Taos and down toward Albuquerque. When we told him that we were going back to Albuquerque for a few days, he said, "Oh, wait! Let me get the chef. He knows a lot of great restaurants to eat at in Albuquerque."
Moments later, David Sellers emerged from the kitchen. An affable man with a shock of silver hair, Sellers was appreciative of our praise for the meals we just enjoyed and he gave us a handful of restaurants in the Albuquerque to check out while we were there. We did check a couple of them out - mainly farm-to-fork restaurants similar to Horno - but they were also a bit out of our price range of what we wanted to pay for a meal.
I really can't say enough about our meal at Horno. Everything from the food to the service to the comfortable atmosphere in the restaurant made it a top-notch experience. Edward was a great server and a cool guy with a lot of great information about Santa Fe and other places nearby. The tuna tartare appetizer that I started out with would have been a great item for a main entree, but the seafood and squid ink capellini was an outstanding dish. My wife absolutely loved her fresh-caught pink grouper with the roasted corn succotash and the roasted tomatoes on a risotto cake with the beurre blanc sauce. And the blueberry "pop-tart" topped with vanilla ice cream with a fresh blueberry compote was a great way to end the meal. There's a lot of great restaurants in Santa Fe, but it would be my recommendation that Horno is at - or close to - the top of your list of restaurants to try if you get to New Mexico's capital city.