When I first moved to the Quad Cities over 30 years ago, I met a guy who lived over in Silvis who took me around to a number of eateries that he loved. Some were really good, others were not. One of the places that he took me to for Mexican food was a place called the Old Palace Tavern in East Moline. I was sort of "meh!" on the place - it was sort of rundown and the food was just all right. Of course, he loved the place, but that was the first and only time I went there. Well, until recently, that is. The original restaurant shut down in 2020, was bought by a local businessman who gutted the building and spruced the place up and reopened it as the Palace Tavern. My wife had been intrigued by the place after reading about it, and she wanted to go over to check it out.
The building in which the Palace Tavern is housed dates back to 1915. The building has housed a pharmacy and a laundromat during the course of its history, but since the 1950's it has been a neighborhood tavern. Different owners have been in charge of the bar over the years and in 2010 Stephanie Brandt became the owner of the Old Palace Tavern. She ran it for 10 years before she was forced to shut her doors due to the lack of business during the pandemic.
After the Old Palace Tavern closed, East Moline native and businessman Larry Anderson came into the picture. Anderson's primary business is East Moline Glass, a business that was started by his grandfather over 60 years ago. In addition to being the President at East Moline Glass, Anderson is also a developer who bought the land that the former Case/International Harvester factory sat upon in East Moline and turned that into a multi-use area called The Bend which features River Bend Park (formerly Murphy Park) - a wonderful outdoor event venue and green space - an events center, an apartment complex, and the Hyatt Place hotel.
Just down the road from the old Case/IH plant was the former Moline-Knight Automobile building that was situated right next to East Moline Glass. Anderson bought that building and was contemplating tearing it down to expand his company. But he developed the old structure into a multi-use building with restaurants, office space, a brewpub, and a live music/event space called The Rust Belt. In the summer of 2020, Anderson took over the Old Palace Tavern and renovated the tired old spot. It took about a year-and-a-half for the renovations to be completed and in late November of 2022, the spot reopened as the Palace Tavern.
It was a Friday night when we decided to head over to the Palace Tavern to get some drinks and food. It's located on 15th Avenue in downtown East Moline, not far from The Rust Belt and East Moline Glass. (see map) My wife had been to the Old Palace Tavern a number of years ago when she was taking art classes at a studio just across the street. She was sort of keen to find out how the place had changed. As I said, I had been in the place once, but that was over 30 years ago and I don't remember much about it.
Going in the front door of the Palace Tavern, we were met by a young lady who said that we could sit anywhere. We checked out the long narrow bar area with dark wood paneling along the wall opposite the bar. A number of high top tables were in front of the wall with antique-style lamp fixtures hanging from a tin-paneled ceiling. The bar area had a nice tiled floor and a classy looking bar and back bar. Other than it was brighter than hell in the bar, and it was loud from all the people talking, I wouldn't have minded to have hung out in the bar.
The dining room off to the side of the bar was much more subdued in its noise level. It featured a handful of booths along one wall with individual wall lights at each table. Smaller 4-seater tables were along the other wall. On the walls were a number of old pictures of East Moline over the years, and on the walk to the restrooms on the far end of the dining room was a case of memorabilia from the local high school United Township. We ended up taking one of the comfy booths in the dining room.
There's a large outdoor patio off the dining room. Formerly a parking lot for the Old Palace Tavern, the patio features a number all-weather tables with chairs, as well as a stage area for live music in warmer months. Strands of programmable colored lights hung across the patio - they were red for the upcoming Valentine's Day when we were there that evening. But the centerpiece of the patio is a large mural on the side of a building that is also owned by Larry Anderson. Local artist Atlanta Dawn was commissioned by Anderson to come up with a mural that depicts life around the Quad Cities. She designed and painted "Midwest Mississippi Waltz", a 115-foot long, 11.5-foot high mural that shows the different cultures of music found in the Quad Cities toward one end, while the other end blends into scenic life on the Mississippi River. (To see a video of the full mural, click here.) With the help of other artists in the Quad City area, it took Dawn a little over two months to complete the mural.
Our server that evening was a young lady by the name of Terrionna. She gave us menus to look over and my wife ordered her normal Tito's and cranberry (with a lime). They had a list of beers that were available in cans and bottles and I ended up getting a Lagunitas IPA. (When we were leaving, we walked through the bar and I saw that Kona Big Wave on tap. I would have gotten that had I known they had it.)
It was a pretty full menu at the Palace Tavern including appetizers, soups & salads, burgers, sandwiches, pizza and calzones. A kids menu was also available at the tavern. I had just come off the road and had a pizza a couple nights before, so I was looking for something along the lines of a burger or a sandwich.
My wife also wanted to eat light, so she went with the Palace Tavern Plantation salad. The Plantation was an old steakhouse in Moline that closed 45 years ago, but is still fondly remembered by longtime Quad Cities residents. They had a garlic dressing for their salads that a number of restaurants in the area have tried to replicate, but most people swear that no place has completely been able to match the flavor of the original Plantation salad dressing. Since we never lived here when the Plantation was in business, we really don't know. My wife asked Terrionna if she could add some protein to the salad and Terrionna said that they could add some grilled chicken to the salad. That's what my wife ordered.
Now, we've had Plantation dressing at other places around the Quad Cities and this seemed to be more like a Thousand Island/garlic dressing, which really wasn't bad. My wife was happy with the Plantation/grilled chicken salad that she ordered. Nice, light, and the chicken was properly grilled.
The sandwich side of the menu wasn't all that extensive. They had a Nashville-hot chicken sandwich which was more of a Buffalo-style sandwich. They had a grilled or breaded pork tenderloin sandwich that I considered for a moment. And they had a Chicago-style Italian beef sandwich on the menu. I decided to just go the burger route and ordered the bacon burger. I had a choice of cheese to put on it, and I went with the Swiss cheese. For sides, I had choices including fries, fried potato salad (I seriously thought about trying that), onion rings, and cole slaw. But they had tots and I had to get those.
The burger was good - nice and flavorful served on a lightly toasted bun with a bacon/tomato jam. Red onion slices, tomatoes and bib lettuce came on the side. I asked Terrionna if they had Cholula for the tots, but all they had was Tabasco. That was fine. I concentrated more on finishing the burger than worrying about the tots - which were also good. My wife even snuck a few tots over to her side of the table to munch on.
The guy in the booth next to us had ordered a pizza and when the waitress brought it out to him, it went right by our table. My wife and I both glanced at it as it went by and it looked interesting. After the guy had finished what he could eat, he got a to-go box for the rest. When he got up to leave, as he was passing our table, my wife said, "Hey, how is the pizza here?" He said it was very good.
"I come over here from Davenport," he said to my wife. "I think it's the best pizza in the Quad Cities." That was enough of an endorsement for us.
So, we went back about a month later and ordered a pizza. We ordered our standard sausage, pepperoni and mushroom. The crust was spongy on the edges, but more thin in the middle. It was cut into strips, Quad City-style, and had crumbled sausage, salty pepperoni, and fresh mushrooms. We noticed that they went light on the cheese, which my wife appreciated.
And it was a good pizza. Not the type we like with large chunks of sausage and a thin crust all around, but fine for what it was. It reminded us a lot of our favorite Quad City-style pizza at Sports Fans in Bettendorf. We ate about half the pizza and took the rest home. Warmed up, it was also pretty good as a leftover.
For our two initial visits to the Palace Tavern in East Moline, we didn't really have anything to complain about. The service was prompt and the staff was friendly, the food was good - but not transforming, and the ambiance was warm and welcoming. The renovations they've done has turned a tired, dingy place into a nice little tavern that is comfortable and pleasant to visit. We are definitely going back to the Palace Tavern at some point to enjoy the patio when the weather gets warmer.