I got into Toronto late in the afternoon during a recent trip up there. I was on my own that evening as my colleague from Montreal was driving in later, and my colleague from France - who was on a France-Australia-Los Angeles-Toronto-France around-the-world trip - wasn't due from in L.A. until around 10:30 that evening. I had it in my mind to find a brewpub for dinner that evening. I ended up Uber-ing to one place near my hotel for dinner and some beers (more on that later on), but it turned out that only it had food at its downtown Toronto location. However, the people at that microbrewery steered me to another place that they knew had craft beer and food - Mascot Brewery. After getting another Uber to pick me up, I took off to head over to Mascot Brewery.
Aaron Prothro is a native of Nova Scotia who moved to Toronto as a young man full of ambition, but really no clue as to what he really wanted to do. Prothro was an athlete and worked out at a local fitness center. He eventually got a job at the fitness center as a personal trainer and competed in local body-building championships.
But he also had an interest in the hospitality industry and had some conceptual ideas of the kind of place that he'd like to run - a chic little restaurant with seasonal menu items and an extensive wine list. Oh! And a second-story bar above the restaurant that would feature artisanal drinks and a D.J. with a thumping sound system. That dream of Prothro's came true when he opened Nyood Restaurant and Bar in February of 2008.
While owning and running Nyood, Prothro and a friend came up with another concept - F-Stop - an EDM (electronic dance music) and hip-hop dance club. But there was something brewing - literally - in his mind. He became immersed in the craft beer community and as a black man he noticed the inclusivity and the laid-back vibe the growing craft beer scene was in Toronto.
Pictured right - Aaron Prothro. Photo courtesy Mascot Brewery Facebook page.
Prothro especially liked the fact that craft beer seemed to bring people together and not try to divide them. He didn't like the technical jargon that some microbreweries used to describe their beers and wanted a place where plain-speak in his beer's descriptions was the norm. And he wanted a brewpub where people could gather and just chill out.
Aaron Prothro sold his interests in Nyood and F-Stop to work on getting his concept of a brewery and taproom up and running. He found a space in downtown Toronto and in May of 2015 he opened Mascot Brewery - the first black-owned brewery in Canada. The original location for Mascot Brewery was on Mercer Street in downtown Toronto, but they moved to their present location on King Street West in 2019.
Also in 2019, Prothro announced they would open up a second location in suburban Etobicoke complete with a brewing facility, tap room, patio and event space, along with a restaurant in collaboration with Matt Basile who owned the popular Fidel Gastro food truck. The pandemic slowed down the progress of the buildout and the new Mastro Brewery location finally opened in June of 2021.
As I said earlier, I set out to go to a brewpub that I thought had food. The Uber driver dropped me off in front of Great Lakes Brewery (see map) and when I walked in, I sort of suspected that they didn't have a kitchen there. After sitting down at the bar and ordering a beer, I asked the bartender if they had food. "No, sorry," she said. "Our downtown location does, but we don't. This is our tap room and retail location." They had a number of beers on tap, and cans of beers for sale in a refrigerator near a wall of wearables that were also for sale.
But I ended up hanging out there for a couple beers talking with the two bartenders who turned out to be wonderful people. Canada "Nice" people. They had a couple hazy IPA's on tap and I tried them both. I ended up getting the HazeMama New England-style IPA that is one of their year-round beers. The place wasn't all that busy and I visited with the bartenders who were intrigued that a guy from Iowa had found their tap room. They were also very helpful in their suggestion of a nearby brewpub that had food - which turned out to be Mascot Brewery.
Getting an Uber from Great Lakes Brewery turned out to be a bit of a challenge as there was a Toronto Maple Leafs hockey match starting just down the nearby Gardiner Expressway in downtown Toronto. It turned out that I had time for one more beer waiting for my Uber ride to show up. As I said, it was a slow evening and the bartenders were happy for the company. And they had great music playing in the background from artists such as Onra, The Herbaliser, and Ă“lafur Arnalds with Bonobo.
Once the Uber driver showed up, it turned out to be less than a 10 minute ride through residential streets of suburban Toronto to the Mascot Brewery. (see map) I found an industrial building which housed some other businesses including a little coffee shop. Mascot Brewery was toward the back of the building with a very nice wood-facade corner beer garden in front of the building.
Opening the door to Mascot Brewery, I found a small bar area with a concrete-faced bar and room for five or six chairs. There were some tables in the bar area where some people were seated. Music from the likes of Bob Marley, Jack Johnson and Red Hot Chili Peppers played on the sound system. I immediately liked the laid-back vibe of the place.
The on-tap brew menu was on the wall just to the left of the bar and very prominent when you walk into the small bar area. There was no one behind the bar and I wondered if there was a dining area in the place.
Just past the bar was a larger room with a larger bar. There were a few people seated in this spacious room, but the bar was also unmanned. A large garage door that opened onto the beer patio was the prominent feature of the beer hall.
A guy came out of nowhere and asked if I needed any help. I told him that I was looking for some beer and some food. He said, "You came to the right place!" I asked him if I could just sit at the bar and he said, "Yeah, I'm in the other room tonight. We don't have this bar up and running tonight."
Back in the smaller bar room, I took a seat at the bar. The bartender's name was Ben and he turned out to be a great guy. He gave me a food menu to look through and I wanted to know what they had for a hazy IPA that evening. They had 16 beers on tap when I was there and Ben told me that that their hazy IPA was called the Juicy J. I tried a sample and immediately signed up for a pint of that after a quick tasting.
The menu at Mascot Brewery wasn't long, but it was certainly interesting. They had grilled octopus on the menu that certainly caught my eye. There was a fennel sausage and rapini dish, as well as a braised short rib served with fresh horseradish. All three of those sounded great. Appetizers included wings, charred Brussels sprouts, and "Bang-Bang" cauliflower bites. And they had other items such as jerk chicken tacos, a chicken Katsu sandwich, and a beer-braised bratwurst plate.
I really considered getting the grilled octopus - I just love grilled octopus. But I ended up getting the Oklahoma-style (cooked with onions on a flat grill) smash burger with mild cheddar cheese and bacon. A side of fries came with the burger. The burger, itself, was very good. It had the very crispy edge that you get with good smash burgers. The cheese oozed out of the burger with each bite, and the grilled onions offered a great flavor complement to the crispy bacon on the burger. I had absolutely no complaints with the burger.
The fries were also very good - while they weren't all that crisp on the outside, they had a wonderful flavor like they had been cooked in beef tallow. The fries were delicious on their own.
I had told Ben of my odyssey that brought me to Mascot Brewery that evening. I told him that I like to find brewpubs during my travels. "There's a lot of excellent brewpubs in the area," Ben told me. And he proceeded to give me a handwritten list of some of his favorites that he suggested I try. He had listed Rainhard and Shacklands breweries at the top of his list. "They're next door to one another, probably about a 15 minute drive from here," Ben told me. "Great beers, great people."
He also mentioned and listed Blood Brothers Brewing which was northwest of downtown Toronto; along with Henderson Brewing Company that collaborated with the Toronto-based rockers Rush for a series of Rush-themed beers. (I've had the Rush golden lager and it's a very good beer.) Closing out his list, he had written down Halo Brewing which was just west of downtown Toronto; and finally he listed Nickle Brook Brewing Company, a brewery in Burlington, ON near Hamilton. "Nickle Brook has a taproom just down the street from Great Lakes," Ben told me. "I really like their beers. They have a stout that I really like."
I told Ben that I was in town for a trade show and I really didn't know if I would have time to get around to any of the breweries he had listed. He said, "Well, hang on to this and when you come back you can check 'em out on your next visit." I didn't know if I would be back in Toronto anytime soon, but it's a guess I'll be back next fall for the trade show.
It was past 9 p.m. and I figured I'd had enough and it was time to get an Uber to get back to my hotel. However, I was having trouble getting a signal from Bell Canada on my phone outside Mascot to use the Uber app. I had to go back in and get the wi-fi password from Ben to be able to get the Uber app to work. He was more than helpful and commiserated with me on the pitfalls of having Bell Canada as a service provider.
I was actually sort of sad when the Uber showed up at Mascot Brewing to take me back to the hotel. The me of 20 years ago would have been taking the Uber to the next craft brewery on the list instead of heading back to the hotel. But I knew we had a long day coming up and it was time to get back to the hotel to rest up. But what a fun night this was! I was able to go to two craft breweries in the Toronto area and have some good beers at both places served by typically friendly Canadians. And the smash burger and fries I had at Mascot Brewing was a spot-hitter, to say the least. I put the list of breweries that Ben gave me on my Google Maps of "Restaurants to Visit" listing for when I do eventually make it back to Toronto at some point. But until then, I'll have great memories of visiting both Great Lakes Brewing and Mascot Brewing on this trip to Toronto.